#1
Posted: 8/21/08 at 12:50pm
I finally got around to seeing THE LITTLE MERMAID last night and I have to say that for $112, I did not feel like I got my money's worth. Not even in spectacle.
The show's plot is very different from that of the movie which is odd because it seems to harp, now, on little subplots and take odd tangents off that do nothing to move the plot along. Many scenes that they took out from the movie are very much missed here as the plot of the movie was much more effective than the plot of the Broadway show.
The only really notable thing about the show is its fantastic score. Even though many of the new songs bog down the plot and are just there to entertain, they are all really memorable songs. I actually left the theater humming some of the songs, which is a rarity in theater nowadays. Also, the orchestrations are gorgeous (and deserved a Tony nomination) and make the musical aspect of the show all the more enthralling.
The book is a total and complete mess. Their attempt to stay true to the film but also create their own story is really lame. Like I said, the book seems to take too many tangents, harp on things that don't further the plot or help develop any of the characters or relationships, and in the end, the corny water-related jokes and terrible puns just make the book even more of a muddled disaster. Doug Wright is a brilliant bookwriter and playwright. I have no idea what happened here...I just don't think he was the right person to hire to write this book for a family-aimed musical. It's a pretty terrible book.
The performances are all passable with three standouts. Sierra Boggess is making a really nice Broadway debut as Ariel. She sings beautifully and even if she plays the role a bit too over-acty, there is a lot of potential busting at the seams. John Tracey Egan is hilarious as Louie (I can't believe he didn't get more recognition for stealing the show with the one scene he was in when the show opened). And Sherie Rene Scott glides through the terrible, wildly underwritten character she's been given with ease. Her voice is amazing as always. The rest of the cast is fine if underhwelming...I really also liked Brian D'Addario as Flounder...his voice is really great. Alan Mingo Jr. was on as Sebastian and was alright.
Okay...now on to the technical aspects of the show. The sets were clunky and at times nice to look at, but overall suffocated the stage and story with too much plastic and those two blown-glass-looking pillars (which I thought were pointless and kinda just distracting...and not in a good way). The costumes are nice for what they are (I mean they are technically impressive but visually jarring at first...in ways that everyone's already mentioned --Flounder is basically wearing a t-shirt, the mermaids have tails coming out of their butts, the eels costumes light up which is a gimmick that loses steam very quickly, and Sebastian's costume is gangly and just weird). The wheelies are so pointless...they hardly use them except for quick scenes where they glide by on them and then kick them back in. I just really think there could've been a better way to technically pull of this show and this is not it.
Francesca Zambello's direction is pretty high-school level. Surprisingly. The choreography is WAY underwhelming.
And this show is also missing a lot of spectacle. It's just all a bit too clunky and not really transcendant. It's really hard for me to put together my thoughts on the show and I hope this review is somewhat clear and readable. I just love the movie so much and the show has a lot of potential to be a really beautiful stage production. This is not it.
*1/2 out of ****
The show's plot is very different from that of the movie which is odd because it seems to harp, now, on little subplots and take odd tangents off that do nothing to move the plot along. Many scenes that they took out from the movie are very much missed here as the plot of the movie was much more effective than the plot of the Broadway show.
The only really notable thing about the show is its fantastic score. Even though many of the new songs bog down the plot and are just there to entertain, they are all really memorable songs. I actually left the theater humming some of the songs, which is a rarity in theater nowadays. Also, the orchestrations are gorgeous (and deserved a Tony nomination) and make the musical aspect of the show all the more enthralling.
The book is a total and complete mess. Their attempt to stay true to the film but also create their own story is really lame. Like I said, the book seems to take too many tangents, harp on things that don't further the plot or help develop any of the characters or relationships, and in the end, the corny water-related jokes and terrible puns just make the book even more of a muddled disaster. Doug Wright is a brilliant bookwriter and playwright. I have no idea what happened here...I just don't think he was the right person to hire to write this book for a family-aimed musical. It's a pretty terrible book.
The performances are all passable with three standouts. Sierra Boggess is making a really nice Broadway debut as Ariel. She sings beautifully and even if she plays the role a bit too over-acty, there is a lot of potential busting at the seams. John Tracey Egan is hilarious as Louie (I can't believe he didn't get more recognition for stealing the show with the one scene he was in when the show opened). And Sherie Rene Scott glides through the terrible, wildly underwritten character she's been given with ease. Her voice is amazing as always. The rest of the cast is fine if underhwelming...I really also liked Brian D'Addario as Flounder...his voice is really great. Alan Mingo Jr. was on as Sebastian and was alright.
Okay...now on to the technical aspects of the show. The sets were clunky and at times nice to look at, but overall suffocated the stage and story with too much plastic and those two blown-glass-looking pillars (which I thought were pointless and kinda just distracting...and not in a good way). The costumes are nice for what they are (I mean they are technically impressive but visually jarring at first...in ways that everyone's already mentioned --Flounder is basically wearing a t-shirt, the mermaids have tails coming out of their butts, the eels costumes light up which is a gimmick that loses steam very quickly, and Sebastian's costume is gangly and just weird). The wheelies are so pointless...they hardly use them except for quick scenes where they glide by on them and then kick them back in. I just really think there could've been a better way to technically pull of this show and this is not it.
Francesca Zambello's direction is pretty high-school level. Surprisingly. The choreography is WAY underwhelming.
And this show is also missing a lot of spectacle. It's just all a bit too clunky and not really transcendant. It's really hard for me to put together my thoughts on the show and I hope this review is somewhat clear and readable. I just love the movie so much and the show has a lot of potential to be a really beautiful stage production. This is not it.
*1/2 out of ****
