so I saw the show last night, and I was overwhelmingly moved by the final 30 minutes. I think it touched a nerve because my Brother is in Afghanistan right now, and right from the start, I associated him with Stark Sands' Character, Raleigh.
SPOILER
those final moments in darkness with the very loud bomb effects, leading into the final picture were so devestatingly powerful, I was close to convulsing in my chair.
END SPOILER
anyway- the whole cast- all around amazing. Not a single weak link among them, and they were commited 100% to bringing this story to us. I loved the themes of hero worship, reality taking over naivety, and brotherhood in the face of adversity. It was all very real to me.
All the effects, like the dust blowing in, for example, were not overdone. Everything was subtle and had a quiet perfection to it. The set was fantastic and conveyed the claustrophobia of the trenches very well, and was enhanced by the wonderfully creative natural lighting with the candles.
AS for the script, some parts are slow, and dated, but it does not have that dated feel to it, thanks to the wonderful direction of the actors. There are small bursts of action that happen throughout to keep your attention, in between long dialogue sections, but as they say in the show, That is what war is. It is waiting for something to happen, and then it happens quickly, is over, and you wait again. But it was the continual payoffs of these wonderful "Bursts" of action that made the whole show one of the best executed Broadway plays I have seen.
If anyone is on the fence about seeing this show- Hop that fence and buy a ticket, you will not regret it.
"I'm an American, Damnit!!! And if it's three things I don't believe in, it's quitting and math."