I suppose I could lump all the classics together i.e Kiss Me Kate, South Pacific, Oklahoma, Brigadoon & West Side Story. Of the last few years it becomes easier, Phantom, Les Miserables, Cats and the like. Of this year, Woman In White. That is more than five. But opinions change as years go by. Or maybe it is easier to compare so certain shows stand out more.
sorry about the re-posting! I'm new to the boards and didn't know you could go through the old stuff! anyways here are my top five in no order except the first:
Q Spelling Bee Wicked Rent Guys and Dolls
my top ten would include things like jersey boys and DRS too though :)
5 Favorite shows (in alphabetical order): Into the Woods Producers Rent Scarlet Pimpernel Spelling Bee
5 Least Favorite shows (also in alphabetical order): Chitty Chitty Bang Bang Dracula the Musical Jackie Mason's Laughing Room Only Ring of Fire Thou Shalt Not (oh, so many more...)