I'm going way back here. There was a song that opened ACT 2 of Skyscraper starring Julie Harris called Delicatessan that stunk worse than a moldy Pastrami sandwich. Almost every song from Man In The Moon. For a non-Broadway show song I pick Space is So Startling (there's Jupiter & there's Mars) from a London cast album from the 60's. I haven't listened to that album in over 30 years & I still can't get that horrible title song out of my head.Shipoopi is a masterpiece of melody & poetry compar...
Runners Up:LEGS DIAMOND MARILYN Winner of the worst ever that I saw: MAN IN THE MOON. The lady sitting in front of us flung her playbill towards the stage at the end. It was a dreadful, incomprehensible piece of crap
13 in 1963-saw HIGH SPIRITS with Tammy Grimes, Bea Lillie & Edward Woodward. Prior to that, at age 10, I saw a professional production of CAROUSEL at the Westbury (L.I.) Music Fair when it was still a tent.
I grew up in the 60's & was a big Doors fan. I really liked their song "Moon of Alabama" (Oh, show me the way to the next whiskey bar...)It wasn't until a few years later that I discovered it was a Kurt Weill song from one of his musicals (Either Happy End or The Rise & Fall of the City of Mahoganny)
Off the top of my head & working backwards: Woman in White Sweet Smell of Success Parade My Favorite Year Sideshow Carrie Merrilly We Roll Along Oh, Brother King of Hearts Henry,Sweet Henry Georgy
This may be a bit obscure but I swear "All You Have To Do is Wait" from City of Angels has the exact same melody as "Going Going Gone" from Lolita, My Love