Mar 29, 2011 — 7:40:06 AM
I don't know anything about the NY production, but I have the Chicago cast recording and saw it mounted in Melbourne recently. I don't mind it, it has some appeal, but as far as a L5Y comparison, it's a watery replica. The characters are nowhere near as finely drawn, the score is nowhere near as strong, memorable or meaningful. Cute and enjoyable, but not on the same level as L5Y (imho).