Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

10 Commandments displayed in public? — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Well, here they are...funny that really only three of then can be enforced by law (murder, theft, and perjury).

I honestly don't know anyone that follows all of these...even when I was raised Southern Baptist...we didn't follow number four. We bought gas, picked up KFC, mowed the grass.


The Ten Commandments

1) I am the Lord thy god, who brought thee out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of bondage.

2) Thou shalt have no other gods before Me.

3) Thou shalt not take the name of the Lord thy God in vain.

4) Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy.

5) Honor thy father and thy mother.

6) Thou shalt not murder.

7) Thou shalt not commit adultery.

8 Thou shalt not steal.

9) Thou shalt not bear false witness against they neighbor.

10) Thou shalt not covet anything that belongs to thy neighbor.


Updated On: 3/3/05 at 11:07 AM

#27

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I don't have a problem with the 10 Commandments being displayed. However, any place that displays them should, at the request of another religious group, display a prominent symbol of that religion.
So go ahead, Texas, show them. But when someone asks for a large Star of David display, you can't deny it. Just suck it up and put it up.
I also think it's funny that people believe our founding fathers were really that devoutly religious. Read their writings. They were very spiritual but pretty unitarian (anyone read Thoreau? The All-Father or the all-seeing eye are pretty generic descriptions for the Christian God).
I also don't even have a problem with the word God on our coins or in our pledge as long as it's there generically as it really is. With the exception of the few religions that are still pantheic (ick, I THINK that's a word), most religions in America worship one god.
#28

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I also have a BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIG problem with the whole 'under God' thing.

It's historical significance was that it was instituted into the Pledge of Allegiance during the Red Scare in order to weed out the Communists.

No wonder people have a problem with it.
"I'm so looking forward to a time when all the Reagan Democrats are dead."
#29

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I have always refused to say the "under god" part, and I'm certainly not a Communist. I'm sure many others have done the same...so much for our brilliant government and their foolproof ploys. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

It's rather frightening what connections the collective mind (inasmuch as there is such a thing) makes with the scantest of data..."You don't believe in God, therefore you must be a Communist/Satanist/Fascist/evil person who must be destroyed".

I just lurve Amurrica, don't y'all? *chews on straw*
Suzanne: I never use catalogs. I'd rather go in the store and see all the salespeople groveling and sucking up to you. Julia: Pardon me, I never knew they were so solicitous at the K-Mart.
#30

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

For those who were asking, my icon is Bette Davis. It's from Watcher in the Woods.
My avatar is a reminder to myself. I need lots of reminders...
#31

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I say why not? They are representative of a moral order that is predominant in this land.

I agree that if they are there, then any legitimately related symbology from other mainstream religions should be allowed as well.

Does a statue of David in a public square mean that Italians have to be nude? (a stretch, I agree... but my point is...) If the "commandments" are part of a work of art (such as a sculpture) they shouldn't be removed because of what they say. That's censorship.
Hamlet's father.
#32

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Religious iconography in artwork spans centuries (nay...millenia) and I have no problem with it. But I'll argue that a tablet with the Ten Commandments listed (and nothing else represented) crosses over from iconography to progpaganda.

The part of the equation that's being left out by many here is that there is a number of Americans who choose not to believe in any form of god. So simply stating 'Let every other religion have access' is ignoring the supposed 7% who choose not to believe in a higher power. Now...that may seem to be a small percentage, but compared to the fact that Jews make up 2% of the population, it's a little less insignificant.

And the 'moral order' predominant in this land is stated quite clearly in our laws and system of government. We certainly do not need a religious list to justify our way of life.
"I'm so looking forward to a time when all the Reagan Democrats are dead."
#33

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I have officially renamed the devil on my left shoulder "Robbie". :)

How does an artists (Guarantee that any sculptor would refer to themselves in that manner, regardless of the job they were commissioned to do) representation of some "historical" words justify the way you live your life? It can be ignored just as easily as any other law or dogma...

Should we go around scratching out and burning down every bit of print that we don't agree with? I don't believe in many things on display in public and private spaces, but I don't argue their right to be present. That's crossing a line that I don't want to cross.
Hamlet's father.
#34

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Son, you're my new favorite poster on this board. I LOVED Watcher in the Woods! Great icon!
And, wow, you guys posted until very late last night. I had to go to bed. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Windy City, on your list, there are only nine of the commandments. Your 1 and 2 are the first commandment. The 2nd is "do not make idols in the form of anything in heaven or on the earth". I think it's appropriate that it was the one that was accidentally left off, since the Christians themselves want to turn a statue of the Ten Commandments into an idol! HAH!

dgrant, to answer to your question from the wee hours of last night re: 10 Commandments displayed in public? , I find it very interesting that when you and I look around and see the order and elaborately constructed systems that govern the natural world, we come to different conclusions. In my mind, I find it indisputable that a higher power instigated the whole process. Do I believe in evolution? I believe in micro-evolution, as in adaptation, because evidence of that is all around me in nature. Not including my own ability to adapt. But in MACRO-evolution? As in, from monkeys? Frankly, I find that HARDER to believe. To me, a great energy or consciousness that permeates all life, connecting us to each other, and gives a will to discover, a desire to better ourselves, feelings of gratification when we help others that don't directly benefit us, gives us a feeling of emotional love that does not exist in other creatures, makes much more sense than a scientific "principle" taken from a source that is replete with contradictions, fallacies, and inaccuracies, and that routinely breaks its own rules, the rules of hypothetical science, simply to maintain that the "core principle" is correct.
Frankly, I don't think we'll ever know what started creation. Was it a Big Bang? I don't know. Like so many other things people argue about, I don't think that it matters. Its certainly something no one will ever be able to prove one way or the other. All I know is what exists right now. All around me I see evidence, that doesn't contradict itself or break its own rules, that convinces me of something greater than the almighty human race.
Is God a man or a woman? Neither. Who friggin cares. Which religion is right? Frankly, I don't think anyone has everything right. The people who thought they did, Jesus shot down from their pedestals pretty quick. Because, in my opinion, they were missing the real "core principle":
!!That we are not in control!!
That has been the greatest truth ever revealed in my life. EVERYTHING in life is about that. Singing, acting, relationships, work. It's all about doing your best and refining yourself TO A POINT. At which moment, you simply have to let go and allow whatever's going to happen to happen.
Faith was never set up to be a massive list of expectations or rules. Why would God, who knows what ridiculous fickle little creatures we are, construct such an impossible standard? That was the very thing Jesus reprimanded the Pharisees for: for turning the worship of God into a litany of criteria to judge others' faithfulness by.
I think the most important thing is simply an acknowledgment. A nod of the head that says, "there's something more to life than my own concerns. There is something greater than myself."
I don't think God wants us to worship him/it/her because he NEEDS it. That's ludicrous! I think he does it to make us less selfish. He knows, ultimately, that it will make us better people: If we are constantly deferring to a higher power, how can we become self-righteous, since we are constantly admitting that nothing is from ourselves?

Anyway, I've gone on for a long time. dgrant, I may be a straight, married man, but I'm in love with your mind. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public? When the bible refers to how God "made us in his own image", I believe that to be conscious thought, a searching mind, the ability to choose and differentiate between what's right and wrong, appropriate, or beneficial. Thus, to do so, whether you know it or not, is to do the will of God. It's also something to be admired, provided the motives are pure: a friend of mine always says, "People are more concerned with BEING right, than DOING right." He is absolutely right. Heh. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?
Word. Word, indeed.
#35

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

B.B. - There's some beautiful language in what you just presented, and interestingly, I'm much more in line with your reaction to the wonders of the perceived universe than you might imagine.

Just a couple of things that immediately came to mind when I read through your post.

First, You assumed that we were coming to different conclusions from our shared observations. I was merely asking for a clarification of your position - but I didn't really go into where I stood, at least as concerned what you had just mentioned.

Also, this statement I found somewhat problematic - "feelings of gratification when we help others that don't directly benefit us, gives us a feeling of emotional love that does not exist in other creatures". The first thing that came to mind seems rather silly, but it did seem to contradict what you were asserting - what about dogs who rescue their owners from a fire? It could be argued that they are simply looking to be rewarded by more love and attention - or even that they're simply preserving their source of survival - but then, why isn't that only what humans are doing? But ultimately, it only seems to address what we know here in our own little corner of the perceivable universe - and I'm not sure what, if any, use there is in distinguishing our experience as sentient creatures from other forms of life. Especially since we have no idea what's really going on in the vastness we are aware of around us.

While that may seem to further justify your perception that there must be a unifying force, or something that provides reason outside of that which we can understand, that's a pretty great leap - although, one which I'm not necessarily disinclined to make myself. However, I certainly see no link between that response to existense, and the current manifestation of deism (man-made religion) that we see around us now.

I myself have found my sense of 'god' (or at least a power outside the confines of my own limited awareness) on more than one occasion. And those experiences are part of the foundation from which I view my own existence. I would never superimpose my ideas and thoughts about what really constitutes life onto another person, though - especially if it will deny them the free will to live life as they see fit. I would seriously prefer if others would grant me that same priveledge.

And thanks for the brain-loving comment. In return, I'll share that you touch my heart by speaking so openly and eloquently about how you FEEL in response to your experience of living - because I feel that's truly what counts.
#36

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I would like to make a distinction, only for the sake of clarifying my own position. I have said on the board before that , when faced with the unknown prospect of our existence, contemplating the possibility of a 'higher power' is absolutely viable - in many ways it is the one most full of hope and promise. However, I have serious difficulty with the man-made interpretations of that impulse that we see manifested as religion - it always seems so incredibly narcissistic and myopic, especially when our awareness is so limited.

Of course, there are those who insist that their religion isn't man-made, but rather the divine intervention of their interpretation of 'god' - or at least someone's interpretation that they accept. Then there's that great leap that's made whereby they claim that, because their vision of god is sacrosanct, everything must be held accountable to those dictates.

As someone who works rather empirically, I am disinclined to accept the words and thoughts of others simply because I'm told 'it is so'. And I certainly don't believe in the willful limitation of someone's freedoms based on those beliefs.

Ultimately, I just want to make clear that it's not the possibility of a 'higher power' that I have a problem with, it's the decision of some to codify that belief of their own and then willfully impose that structure on others around them.
#37

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

In retrospect, I shouldn't have used that as one of my "reasons". You are absolutely correct, it is beyond our abilities (at the moment) to determine the feelings of other creatures because we're limited to our own forms of communication. Especially since I DO believe that my cat loves me dearly. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public? But, I don't believe that the depth and myriad of facets that comprise human love is possible within creatures whose very existence is much simpler than our own. True, that's a leap, but I think you see my reasoning: In a simple mind, things are not complicated. But, no need to get into the spiritual ramifications of that, we'll save that for the "Are my pets going to heaven, too?" thread. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I also tend to approach things from a logic standpoint. I have a hard time buying what I refer to as "church-speak" from other believers. I don't want to hear about how someone simply "knows" that God exists, I want them to show me the evidence that points them in that direction. I see it in the meticulous contruction of nature and, oversimplified, in the amazing network of human emotion and intellect that we have not yet begun to plumb the depths of. There are these great moments of epiphany when you see HOW everything is connected. It's more than a feeling. (cue Boston...) re: 10 Commandments displayed in public? It's as if you're witnessing the schematic of the universe unfold before your eyes. Sounds pretentious, I know. But if I hadn't experienced it on many occasions, I don't think I would believe what I believe. Random occurences don't sway my beliefs. But, if something is revealed over and over and over again, I'm inclined to sit up and take notice.
I would completely agree that religion has BECOME narcissistic and myopic. As all things do, it began with the best of intentions. It was an attempt to quantify something in order to make it more accessible and manageable. But that's the whole point! To believe in God means that you have to accept what cannot be clearly delineated and quantified. It cannot be a series of infallible rules, because it concerns life, and life is about adaptation and choices. But, as humanity has done in all of recorded history, we break it down to gain control of it. We simplify it so it exists on our own terms. And in doing so, lose site of everything it was meant to be in the first place.

It has been my experience that the bible is simply ONE pathway to God. It even says so itself. "Since the creation of the world, God's invisible qualities have been made clear, so that all men are without excuse." The proof is in the world around us.
And yet, even as I say that, I myself do not believe in the infallibilty of biblical scripture. There ARE universal truths within it, that is simply undeniable. But, I still occasionally hear things about how "God is a man, because it says so in the bible." People seem to contend that the bible was written in a vacuum and that the actual HAND OF GOD picked up a pen and wrote the scriptures. No, it was some old Israelite dudes. And they filtered what they saw in the world around as evidence of God through their own cultural values, which just happened to be a patriarchal society. Thus, God was a man. Contemporary linguists say that the next great development in the English language will be the creation of a gender-neutral pronoun. Thank God. Maybe then we can have an honest conversation about it.
I would contend that just because you believe in a higher power doesn't mean it makes life full of hope and promise. There is an enormous misconception out there among all faith communities that "God wants me to be happy." I think that's incredibly presumptious and, frankly, wrong. Everything in the bible speaks to God wanting you to worship him and acknowledge that he is there IN SPITE of your degree of happiness. God is not a slot machine that will eventually pour forth wealth and happiness if you pray enough. It's a pretty cold image of the Creator I have, but ultimately the image of Santa Claus God came from the very thing you mentioned: narcissism. To actually presume that God, the force that binds the universe together, is somehow concerned with the trappings of my life is self-centeredness at its highest. That's not to say that I don't think God COULD care about each individual, he may and Jesus's teachings were largely based on the fact that God sees everyone's heart. I just think it's selfish to think that he is "constantly watching over me" as the many songs say. But then my view of God as the preeminent force in the cosmos is not very popular next to the Buddy Christs and McJesus of today.

All that being said, I think you're right: we do believe a lot of the same things. We just use different terms to express it. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?
Word. Word, indeed.
#38

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Damn, the "Internal Server Error" must've been a doozy. I couldn't post for like 20 minutes!
Word. Word, indeed.
#40

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Ah, Chrisopher...you took the bait!

Of course things shouldn't be censored. But there is a point at which displaying something religious ON GOVERNMENT PROPERTY for the express purpose of linking those commandments to our judicial system crosses a line. The fact is the government needs not come down on any side of religion to express it's moral order. Our laws are more than enough...and if not, then we need to fix our system of government.

Move the friggin' thing to a church. Or a Christian school. Or someone's yard. Display it proudly in public...just as I would (if I were a certain type of gay man) display a rainbow flag from my porch (were I to actually have a porch). The difference is that it is not on governmental property and is, therfore, not being condoned by the government.

We are talking about a VERY specific piece of art in which commandments...rules...are on display. Were it a copy of the Pieta, I would have no problem, because it is a sculpture that is not espousing any sort of religious dogma. It is simply depicting an event from history. As is the relief of Moses with the Commandments that is part of the architecture on diplay in the Court (of which I have no problem).
"I'm so looking forward to a time when all the Reagan Democrats are dead."
#41

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

I'll always take your bait, Robert. It's more fun that way. I will acknowledge and agree with your point to some extent. I wouldn't be putting up new installations necessarily, but shouldn't the line be drawn at taking old ones out?

Isn't it a little bit like destroying a tunnel of the underground railroad in the deep south, because the citizens disagree with it?
Hamlet's father.
#42

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Well...I certainly am not advocating the destruction of these monuments. I'm saying move them to a different public space...on on privately owned land.
"I'm so looking forward to a time when all the Reagan Democrats are dead."
#43

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

The country was certainly NOT founded on Judaeo-Christian principles.

The Founding Fathers were Unitarians and Freemasons.
#44

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

One of the commandments is "Thou Shalt Not Lie"

You're putting these commandments in front of a courthouse where a bunch of Lawyers and possible politicians work...Isn't that hypocritical?
"Do you know what pledge time is, Andrew"? said the PBS Executive. "Yes", Lloyd Webber replied. "My 50th birthday special must be one program that gets done a lot." "No", mused the man from PBS heedlessy. "Not so much. Our Stephen Sondheim Carnegie Hall concert. That's a big one." Spoons, forks and knives seemed suddenly to suspend their motion in horror, all around the table.
#45

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

B.B.- Concerning your statement, "I would contend that just because you believe in a higher power doesn't mean it makes life full of hope and promise." I'm not saying that it necessarily leads naturally one into the other. But, I do feel that if you have a sense of something beyond the tactile immediacy of what you see/smell/hear/etc., then it does provide more of an opportunity for hope than blatant nihilistic existentialism - which is where some of the world seems to have gotten mired.

#46

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

Excellent point, dgrant. As always. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?
So, to sum this thread up since it looks as though it's headed for the obscurity of the dreaded PAGE 2:
No. It is not okay to display the Ten Commandments in governmental buildings.
That is all. re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?
Word. Word, indeed.
#47

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

bette davis was going to be my second guess. i didn't know anyone else liked watcher in the woods! it was quite scary when i was a tot. actually it still is. but the beeeest would be what ever happened to baby jane and hush hush sweet charllotte.

leave it to me to take a thread about God and change it to a thread about bette davis...
#48

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

feinstein - there are some around here who would say they are one and the same re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

If you like Bette, and you haven't seen them, you MUST watch All About Eve and Jezebel.
#50

re: 10 Commandments displayed in public?

For some reason, all I could hear in my head just then was Anne Baxter saying, "Oh Moses, Moses, Moses."

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $101