I don't really care for "Daleks in Manhattan"/"Evolution of the Daleks," either. I probably would have been fine with it as a single episode, but the plot didn't really earn being a two-parter. I also didn't really like "Fear Her" or "42."
I agree with most of the favorite episodes. "The Empty Child" is really the only time I felt that a Doctor Who episode was genuinely creepy (which isn't a criticism, because that's not why I watch the show). "Parting of the Ways" is of course brilliant, and "Doomsday" was
devastating and some of the best acting I've ever seen on television. I also love "Silence in the Library"/"Forest of the Dead," particularly the latter -- Donna is just wonderful in that episode. And I also love "The Girl in the Fireplace," both for the story, relationship development, and some brilliant one-liners and comedic scenes ("What's a horse doing on a spaceship?" "Mickey, what's pre-Revolutionary France doing on a spaceship? Get a little perspective!").
Rose will probably always be my favorite companion, but I'll chalk that up to being a sucker for doomed love stories. Her episodes are generally my favorite to watch on repeat viewings because of the dynamic between Rose and the Doctor and all the different things that are going on there. But I adore Donna, too, and when I think of specific scenes that stick out in my mind as being great, a lot of them involve her: her conversations with the Doctor in "Runaway Bride," hearing the song of the Ood, "You fought them off with a water pistol?! I bloody love you." in "Fires of Pompeii," "Is that Time Lord for 'Really not all right at all'?", everything with her in "Journey's End." I don't find series 3 as compelling on the whole, and I think that's because, as badass as Martha objectively is, she was pretty together to start with, and she's the companion who had the least to gain/learn about herself from traveling with the Doctor. In fact, in some ways her relationship with him held her back. Interesting to see the darker, insensitive side of him, though.
And, um, I think I'm kind of in love with David Tennant. Love Eccleston, too, but I'm a sucker for the dynamics of Tennant's Doctor. The Doctor is such an interesting character in his loneliness and otherness, and I'm glad that the show explores that quite a bit.
Updated On: 2/8/10 at 07:33 PM