Art Direction and Costume Design Oscars

Who wins these two categories?

Art Direction:
Good Night, and Good Luck
Harry Potter
King Kong
Memoirs of a Geisha
Pride & Prejudice

Costume Design:
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Memoirs of a Geisha
Mrs. Henderson Presents
Pride & Prejudice
Walk the Line

Am I crazy for picking Memoirs for both? Even though the movie got luke-warm reception by the critics, I think it isn't a stretch to say it was still one of the most beautiful-looking flicks this year.

---

I think Geisha is a smart choice in these categories. The only competition here would be KK for Art Direction.

It's interesting that Geisha pulled out 6 noms--as many or more than all the Best Pic noms, except Brokeback. That, the fact that the Academy will overlook poor reviews/box office in the tech categories, and that most everyone agrees that Geisha looked gorgeous gives Geisha a nice edge.

---

I was just about to say the same thing. GNGL for art direction.

---

Totally agree w Geisha. ( this is actually the qualifying question( best costume) for my Oscar pool.

It's going to be Geisha for both. Hands down.

As great as GNGL was, it's going home empty handed.

---

The art direction for Kong was amazing; I'd really love to see it upset Geisha. Their recreation of 1930s New York so vivid and meticulous.

---

Kong for Art Direction, Mrs. Henderson for Costumes (i know it will probably be Geisha, but Mrs. Henderson was such a better film).

---