Firstly, I like Archuleta. He's my current favorite. Is he perfect?, no. But he's young, there's no denying there's genuine talent there and I think that his full bodied "entertainer" will emerge with time.
I think David seems like a sweet, somewhat shy and/or awkward, teenager, who likes singing. Perhaps he is touched by such an overwhelming show of support for his performances. Yes, he did Star Search and a few local morning talk shows - how many peoole saw those? This is American Idol. TV's #1 show. He is being praised, cheered for, hailed as the new king...that's gotta be wild for the kid.
Perhaps, he is usually an outsider in school, thought of by his peers as "that werd singing kid who is always in talent shows" and "thinks he's a big deal b/c he was on Star Search." To suddenly feel this accepted may be overwhelming, intoxicating, dumbfounding.
That's my take. (I've rambled on a littletoo much.)
Laughter is much more important than applause. Applause is almost a duty. Laughter is a reward.
Carol Channing