See, that's how I also feel about Green Day's music. Ironically, I, for the most part, love the cast album to "American Idiot." The show was awful, but the album was great. Could be because Billie Joe was not singing and I didn't want to claw out my eardrums.
Though if you were to give me the choice between Green Day and "Glee does Green Day," I'll take Green Day. Glee has the ability to suck the life out of every song they do. Minus Bieber. Bieber fit because he sucks the life out of everything, too.
"And I'm a grown up....I don't go on vacations....I go to Broadway." - dramamama611
"Even I think that's hot, and I'm a straight guy. If I ever become gay he is the reason." - Drunk Chita Rivera on Gavin Creel
"Leia947 is my theatre mamma, and I love her for it." - AndAllThatJazz22