@JordanC: I think that was JLO was somewhat overexposed at the time of GIGLI's premier and was experiencing a backlash akin to the one that Beyonce is undergoing currently. Movie studios, record labels, magazine publishers, including tabloids, and publicists shove these celebrities down our throats with tons of fodder unrelated to their craft. There in lies the problem.
Their dating habits, egos, signature merchandise, and award show appearances eclipse their artistry prompting those with discerning tastes to start maligning them at every turn. Then, the critics turn on them. Today, every tidbit pop/rap star and celebrutante has a fragrance line out. Collectively, they've cheapened the "star" brand.
#FactsMatter...your feelings not so much.