Actually, PJ, Joe said he was weird looking in his original post. Others echoed it.
So the ones who find him gorgeous are the contrarians in this case, no?
Well I just think he's handsome. What does that make me?
Someone expressing your opinion without worrying about others'?
My point was just that I think it's entirely possible for one group to find him attractive and one group to find him not and for both groups to be telling the truth (and not just doing it to piss off the other group).
Also that it wasn't one person versus "everyone else."
Oh. In that case then, I think he's butt ugly and if a wet fart had a baby with a queef, it would grow up to look like him.
He sort of looks like he's always smelling that baby.
"Tell the guy who thinks I'm weird looking I love him THIS MUCH."
"Tell the guy who thinks I'm weird looking I love him THIS MUCH."
"Tell the guy who thinks I'm weird looking I love him THIS MUCH."
"Tell the guy who thinks I'm weird looking I love him THIS MUCH."
"Tell the guy who thinks I'm weird looking I love him THIS MUCH."
Apparently, my self-ban from this thread lastly a brief period of time.
To be clear, I don't care if anyone finds Andrew Rannells talented or good looking.
I do find it a little gross to refuse to call the actor by his name and insinuate that he got the role in MORMON by sucking the director's dick. That...is ugly.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
I am trying not to provoke Robbie any more, but seriously PJ you are NOT helping your case.
Hey guy who thinks I'm weird looking
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
NO thatz RO-Z O'Runnells
ANDREW: They said you're weird looking.
(JOSH laughs.)
ANDREW: But then this one guy said I was weird-looking too.
(JOSH laughs again.)
JOSH: You are.
ANDREW: And then this one guy said I sucked Trey Parker's dick to get the job!
(JOSH laughs then stops.)
JOSH: You didn't?
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/16/07
For what it's worth, I've always found Josh Gad much more doable than Andrew Rannells, but I know tastes in men tend to swim against the current.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
I in no way meant to imply that Andrew Rannells got his role in The Book of Mormon by putting out.
You didn't imply it.
a one-trick pony who blew the director.
You stated it outright.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
No no no it's this godawful show he got by putting out for Ryan Murphy. That is seriously the ONLY explanation.
Updated On: 9/20/12 at 04:45 PM
"I would like it if the Rannell's character could make a face that acknowledges he's being ridiculous when he reveals his preference for an underweight baby. I'd like it if a person who acknowledges his own failures gets righteous at a bigot like the guy in the store."
Absolutely, and that would make a big difference to me. Unfortunately, that's not the way Murphy likes to play that kinda humour, as Strummer pointed out, he doesn't help stage actors tone down their reactions--he seems to love that. (And it has gotten worse--one thing that helped make Nip/Tuck work, early on anyway, was the acting even at the most ridiculous and over the top scenario--the show lost it and even the actors spoke out about how horrible they found their material, but...)
As for if Rannells' looks. I find him attractive (less so when playing this role, I admit), but I think it's fair to call him kinda odd looking. He doesn't have the typical, (often bland) leading man look (think someone like Brandon Routh--playing gay in that other gay sitcom coming out, Partners). Which makes him more interesting looking and--to me--more attractive due to that.
Videos