I posted on the ap.org boards that I wasn't a fan of the "idea," meaning the RENT movie in general, but someone was confused as to what I meant, so I posted this:
Okay, here's the short version of my thoughts on this all...
I'm not a fan of the movie in general. I don't think that the essence of what RENT is will translate well to film unless it's handled VERY carefully, and I don't think that Chris Columbus is the right person to be handling such precious cargo. I think my biggest issue with the movie is that I'm not sure how much I feel anyone has the right to do what they're doing with Jonathan's work when he's not around to have input. A LOT of changes are being made, most notably with the music.
As for the casting - I'm torn. Since the movie is happening whether I like it or not, yes, I think it would be lovely for fans to see the OBC up there. Do I think it's the best thing for the film? No. They're all AT LEAST in their mid-30's, and I'm not sure they can believably play early 20's. I also believe that RENT should still now be about what it was when it was fresh - it should be about fresh, new talent. I'd love to see a bunch of young unknowns get into these roles for the movie.
That's basically what I meant. Oh well. Come what may.... I suppose that just about covers it. And I know I'm being selfish in saying that I'd hate for him to become a big movie star and become totally inaccessible. That's what I love about theatre actors... *sigh*
That's not a valid point, but I figured I'd add it.
Hey. Elaborate Lives just came on iTunes. *sob*
A work of art is an invitation to love.