Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

The difficulty and reality of AIDS in our world today.

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

The difficulty and reality of AIDS in our world today.

Perhaps Mr. Kramer should officially change his name to Cassandra (Apollo caused the gift that he gave Cassandra to be twisted, making everyone who heard her true and accurate foretellings of future events believe that they were instead hearing lies.)

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/02/15/health/15aids.html?ei=5065&en=4f6e4d4582cd7b82&ex=1109048400&partner=MYWAY&pagewanted=print&position=

Updated On: 2/15/05 at 02:44 AM

#2

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Please excuse me for the following rant. If you have no interest in reading yet another person screaming into the dark, then by all means just continue on about your business.

**********

I, for the most part, am a very compassionate and empathetic person. The journey of my own life has taught me not to judge too harshly the trials and tribulations of others. BUT, I am beyond all understanding - or even caring - as concerns young gay men who want to carry on as if reality doesn't exist.

I don't have many gay friends in my life at this point. Some, but not many. And you know why? Because all of the beautiful, talented, capable, vibrant and alive young gay men I knew in my youth are dead. Every single one of them. I went to so many funerals, and sat with so many families who had lost their loved ones, that I finally had enough.

I used to work with AIDS patients, but I had to stop. I dealt with just one too many men who really only lamented the fact that they couldn't ever do again what led to their predicament in the first place.

The fact that all this time has gone by, and all this death has occurred, and STILL there are many who want to carry on as if Babylon were Eden makes me beyond the scope of giving a damn.

I was there when it unfolded the first time, and it almost killed me - and I wasn't even sick. I WILL NOT participate again in the willful destruction of any lives.

Eventually, maybe those who refuse to accept what is will pull their heads out of their butts - or their sex partner's - and realize that there is CERTAINLY more to life than what exists in their crotch. Until that time, I couldn't care less if they live or die. I will save my time, energy and compassion for people who revere the precious gift of their lives.
#4

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

It breaks my heart, Blue, it really does. SO pointless - but then, it was pointless the first time they wanted to act like they were invincible - or that it really didn't matter. It matters a GREAT deal.

By the way, I LOVE your current icon - one of the things I'm trembling with excitement for re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?
#5

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

DGrant: I am gay, and I completely understand what you're saying, and couldn't agree more. The lives of so many people I know literally revolves around whether or not they will get ass by the end of the night. They don't care from who, where, or how - as long as the deed is done. I truly do not understand it, and never will.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson
#6

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

DGrant, I am so sorry you had to suffer.

Thank you for your comments - it is unfortunate that it is still necessary. I hope that people will take heed and reform their ways.
Deet: Shira, I Love You!
#7

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Munk - there are times, although they are few and far between at this point (20+ years is a long time re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?) when I STILL have nightmares about sitting in community hearings about whether or not to close the baths. The EXTREME vehemence demonstrated by some of those men as they screamed about their right to do as they pleased with their bodies, results be damned. And believe me, I know all about how there 'wasn't complete information' and 'where we were in the development of our sexual freedom'. I also remember thinking even then that Larry was right on when he asked if it didn't make sense to stop fu*king for a moment until we figured this out, or we might DIE. It seems that the same feelings hold sway - only THIS time there's too much knowledge to feign ignorance.

Updated On: 2/15/05 at 04:05 AM

#8

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

I think I can understand your need to rant. Moreover, I fail to understand why anyone (Note: I did not say gays) who cares one iota for their fellow human beings is not driven to anger and despair over this terrifying form of mass suicide.

Some points I picked up from the article:
Kaiser is quoted as saying "Gay men do not have the right to spread a debilitating and often fatal disease... a person who is H.I.V.-positive has no more right to unprotected intercourse than he has the right to put a bullet through another person's head,"

The first thought that came to my mind was hearing about a number of legal cases where an HIV-infected male was tried for attempted murder after raping a female. The rape was one indictment, the attempted murder through the spread of the disease was another. So why isn't the life of another male shown the same respect? If a man (or woman) who is AWARE that they are HIV-positive engages in unprotected sex with a partner of either sex, then aren't they guilty of attempted murder? Perhaps making that the law is the kind of serious action that must be taken before the people carrying the virus take it seriously.

---------
The article went on to say that 25% of all gay men in NYC had tried crystal meth in the last few months.

If that's true then I'm not sure if ANYTHING can be done to stop the spread of this disease. That kind of complete disregard for their own lives can only logically be extended to others. God help them - and us.
---------------
"Walt Odets, a clinical psychologist and the author of "In the Shadow of the Epidemic: Being HIV-Negative in the Age of AIDS," said he thought such intervention smacked of a witch hunt.
He and others said it would be more effective to try to identify the underlying causes of drug abuse and self-destructive behavior, including the difficulty of living in a society that rejects committed gay relationships while condemning homosexuals for having sex outside those relationships. Gay men, he said, are using methamphetamines as an anti-depressant"

Until people like this get their heads out of the sand and face the stark reality of the situation, it's never going to get better.

--------------

And I repeat - God help us all.




www.thebreastcancersite.com
A click for life.
mamie4 5/14/03
#9

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Shira - what was it Yente said in Fiddler, something like, "We suffer in silence"?

Fu*k that! re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

And as you well know, I am certainly not alone - in this or any other suffering. It's just INFURIATING when there really are things that can be done to avoid it!
#10

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Mamie - I actually agree IN THEORY with what Dr. Odets posits. But ultimately, I still believe MORE in the imperative of personal responsibility.

I'm thinking right now of Bill Cosby's recent tirade against the black community, exhorting them to take hold of their own destinies, instead of looking to lay the responsibility at someone else's feet. These young men have NO ONE to hold responsible but themselves.

And I happen to agree that someone who knowingly transmits this virus should be held liable.
#11

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

It's something I will never understand. Everyone knows that those filthy "baths" are just a breeding ground for every disease, and are infested with men either too ugly to get action on their own, or too sick to get anything in a room that's not dark. That is the main reason I despise going out in the gay scene - and why I've stopped. Most gay men cannot just go out and have fun - every single gay bar and club that I have EVER been to (which is a lot, however briefly) is literally just a hook up bar. You go there alone, pick out a guy, and bring him home. I am so sick of the mindset of these men, it is disgusting and sad. It is very well illustrated in A HOME AT THE END OF THE WORLD with Dallas Roberts' character. I think much of it has to do with the feeling of being invincible - and I know, because I'm 19 years old and and relate (though not about sex) - you feel like your whole life is ahead of you, you're only starting out, you have too much going for you for anything bad to happen or you're too rich and fabulous to ever get AIDS, and the complete mindset of "if could never happen to me." And those with that mindset, before they know it, are the ones who end up ashamed of themselves. That's another reason I think tha AIDS epidemic is stronger than ever - it's not 100% always a matter of rampant, random sex with many parteners - sometimes, in my opinion - men are spreading the disease without even knowing they have it. And believe me, I'm not saying it's fine in that case - but as long as you don't know for sure if you're infected or not, the party will never end. If you forget about it, it must not really be there. However, as soon as they set foot in a doctor's office and are told that they are positive, it's like it's suddenly real - as if it wasn't before. And there's a huge sense of shame. The reason that so many gay men have AIDS isn't a secret - it's obviously because of sex - so if you're a gay man who is diagnosed with HIV, an overwhelming sense of you feeling dirty about yourself, not good enough for anyone or anything - that sort of thing. That's just what I gather about the entire situation.

But you're right - if people started RIGHT NOW never ever again having unprotected sex for the rest of their lives - which isn't a huge impossible task - we would slowly see the decrease and eventual disappearance of the AIDS virus, I'm sure of it. But with the way some people act, only having protected sex seems as if it's the most difficult task in the entire world. So sad.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson
#12

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

And what's REALLY sad, Munk, is that this dance has been going on for almost a QUARTER of a CENTURY! Same thoughts, same excuses and same outcome.
#13

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

I do not understand it. Perhaps it's because so many gay men have romantic ideals? Maybe they find something depressingly satisfying in seeing themselves rot away.

I was more or less kidding, but you have to wonder...

Also, I think another reason it just keeps spreading is because once someone who has tons of random sex finds out they're HIV positive, they're not going to stop. And because their life is ruined, why not ruin other's lives as well - so they go off and bang whoever they can in the most unsafe manner - so maybe they won't feel so quite alone. Who knows. I shouldn't have gotten involved in this conversation - I have class in the morning, still haven't read a play, and am going to be pissed about THIS all night....
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson
#14

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Unfortunately, I entirely understand your plight, Munk re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Go read your play and keep living your life - because THAT you are in charge of!
#15

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

I don't know if I can get through all of THE GOVERNMENT INSPECTOR and actually absorb any of it, I'm falling asleep. I've already tried to stay awake through HEDDA GABLER and THE CENCI...aaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhh.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy." -Charlie Manson
#16

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Aww... I thought this thread was about Kramer's assertion that Abe Lincoln was gay!

Munkus - if you are bored by reading the play, rent the movie THE INSPECTOR GENERAL with Danny Kaye. Same story - plus songs!
#17

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Last week I had a nineteen year old patient who was newly diagnosed with HIV. He's such a nice, articulate, and smart young guy. His partner is ten years older than him and I don't know his HIV status. But I kept thinking, "This doesn't have to be."

Youth in general seem to think they're invincible. They take all kinds of risks. I don't know what it takes to bring the message home.
#18

re: What if Larry Kramer was right all along?

Thank you DGrant for your appropriate level of passion and outrage on this subj. Just seeing the NY Times cover story today gave me heartburn.

The supreme irony in the timing of this new case isn't lost on any of us. Gay people are fighting not to be viewed as 2nd class citizens in this society. America is currently bipolar about the impact of gay culture and gay people. On the one hand, quick to embrace the homosexual aesthetic in style--as arbiters of taste--and as masters of witty repartee. ("We don't run the world, we just design it!" carried to the max, complete with flowing cosmos and looking good in Prada.) To my mind, this is always "easy tolerance," since it allows gays a place at the (beautifully set) table, so long as they are pretty, witty, and can help you fix your living room or clean the detritus from your boring closet.

On the other, there is a widening fear of gay people seeking a classically "ordinary" place in society--as neighbors, as parents, as monogamous couples who commit to one another for life. Outside of NY, Miami, and the Castro (to name but 3), there is an America full of the latter type of gay men. People NOT invested in 'the scene,' but in carving out successful lives, professional and personal, with no more promiscuity and infidelity than exists in the straight world (i.e. to share the range of human experience with the same number of ups/downs--flaws.) Yes America -- some gay men are not only dull, they are boring, their goals and dreams painfully similar to those of everyone else.

Those "ordinary" people are in grave danger of being identified by the more public poster children for 'gay life' (a comparatively small sliver of the total homosexual population) -- the young urban gay male whose singular focus is sybaretic experience and living in the moment, their own role in their culture's struggles for equality be damned. As the larger community struggles for respect and to have minimal rights, it's time for the kind of hard look at the price being paid for the actions of those poster children. The lives and futures and rights of an entire, loving, portion of this society will be asked to pay for the actions of a small percentage. As many have observed, only the gay community can fix itself. But the future of the community's profile and place in this country's history is at stake. Those here who are older: Remember when gay people fought to not be identified with AIDS? Remember how powerful and postive that fight was? How sad that it might have been in vain.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling

Updated On: 2/15/05 at 09:26 AM

#20

re: what if larry kramer was right all along?

how about a shock campaign? why doesn't gmhc or act up or somebody finance a multi million dollar national ad campaign showing photos of a young and vibrant gay man in various poses from his life with a voice over, "sex is so much better without condoms. the drugs can handle any symptoms even if do get something. i won't suffer anything for years. by that time they'll have a cure." then cut to the same man, fully symptomatic, at death's door, on his hospital bed saying, "it's not like i'll die or anything, right?" black screen. graphic, "it's not worth your life. use a condom. every single time."

it would of course necessitate finding someone who fit the bill who's willing to put their life out there as an open book. someone who's willing to be the poster child for what not to do. i dunno, maybe scare tactics don't work. maybe it'd backfire somehow, but at least people would talk about it. a national campaign like that would generate conversation at the very least and people talking about it is better than people whispering and not talking about it.

hell do a series of them with the tagline changed to personalize it to the person being portrayed. have an african american woman with the tagline showing that statistically they are fastest growing group of new infections. show one with a white couple and have the twist be that he's playing on the side and brought her home a present. add to the tagline, "because you really never know."

or am i horribly mistaken here?
r.i.p. marco, my guardian angel.

...global warming can manifest itself as heat, cool, precipitation, storms, drought, wind, or any other phenomenon, much like a shapeshifter. -- jim geraghty

pray to st. jude

i'm a sonic reducer

he was the gimmicky sort

fenchurch=mejusthavingfun=magwildwood=mmousefan=bkcollector=bradmajors=somethingtotalkabout: the fenchurch mpd collective

Updated On: 2/15/05 at 09:30 AM

#21

re: what if larry kramer was right all along?

Actually, papa, I think there was a short-lived campaign somewhere (I think in the UK) which contrasted photos of people ravaged by HIV with pictures of their healthier, buffer selves. It appeared on bus shelters and subways and was attacked by HIV advocacy groups as "stigmatizing" the disease.

"Everyone knows that those filthy "baths" are just a breeding ground for every disease, and are infested with men either too ugly to get action on their own, or too sick to get anything in a room that's not dark."

Oh, you'd be surprised. There are MANY men who go to the baths who are stereotypically hot and desirable. The baths aren't even that much about sex per se: they are about connecting, and feeling, even temporarily, that you're wanted and not lonely.

"Most gay men cannot just go out and have fun - every single gay bar and club that I have EVER been to (which is a lot, however briefly) is literally just a hook up bar. You go there alone, pick out a guy, and bring him home. I am so sick of the mindset of these men, it is disgusting and sad."

The one thing I've found with bars (and I've been in one or two in my life) is that the newer and hotter the bar, the more ear-splitting the music. You can't hear yourself think let alone have a conversation.

The question for gay men is how do we enjoy the flirting (and no matter how old you get, munk, men LOVE to flirt)and the chase without instantly turning it a quick McSex situation?


"Christ, Bette Davis?!?!"

Updated On: 2/15/05 at 09:38 AM

#22

re: what if larry kramer was right all along?

yeah, see that's what i worried i would be attacked here for doing because as ya'll know, i'm in league with satan and his minions. i can understand that perspective, but if the problem is growing then shouldn't every option be on the table?
r.i.p. marco, my guardian angel.

...global warming can manifest itself as heat, cool, precipitation, storms, drought, wind, or any other phenomenon, much like a shapeshifter. -- jim geraghty

pray to st. jude

i'm a sonic reducer

he was the gimmicky sort

fenchurch=mejusthavingfun=magwildwood=mmousefan=bkcollector=bradmajors=somethingtotalkabout: the fenchurch mpd collective
#23

The Normal Heart nailed it in April of 1985

From THE NORMAL HEART, the protagonist, Ned takes a stand:

"...Why didn't you guys fight for the right to get married, instead of the right to legitimize promiscuity?...

... I belong to a culture that includes Proust, Henry James, Tchaikovsky, Cole Porter, Plato, Socrates, Aristotle, Alexander the Great, Michaelangelo, Leonardo da Vinci, Christopher Marlowe, Walt Whitman, Herman Melville, Tennessee Williams, Byron, EM Forster, Lorca, Auden, Bacon, James Baldwin, Harry Stack Sullivan, Dag Hammarskjold... These are not invisible men...

"...the only way we'll have real pride is when we demand recognition of a culture that isn't just sexual. It's all there, all through history we've been there; but we have to claim it, and identify who was in it, and articulate what's in our minds and hearts and all our creative contributions to this earth...

... And until we do that ... we're doomed."
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling

Updated On: 2/15/05 at 09:50 AM

#24

The Normal Heart nailed in in April of 1985

DGrant - Thanks for posting that article. I'm also shocked at how many guys are willing to risk their lives as well as the lives of others to get off. Munkustrap, I do believe there are those men out there who are infected without knowing it, but it's not like they had NO IDEA after 20 years that they could get infected from participating in unprotected sex, so I do have a very difficult time sympathizing with those who engage recklessly in that activity. I think the idea of intervention is great. Even Queer as Folk behaves as if gays have some sort of RIGHT to promiscuity and public sex that does not apply to the rest of the world. Sorry girls, but it ain't true. Is it a direct link to this new strain of HIV, maybe not, but it is highly influential in the engagement of activity that leads to unprotected sex. I know it's not "cool" to be somewhat prudish about circuit parties and the average float at the Pride Parade, but we're getting to the point where there is less and less to be proud about. We speak of contempt when a straight person claims AIDS is a "gay disease", but we have made it a staple in nearly every piece of gay art, music and literature since the mid-80s and STILL we have the despicable hypocrasy to continue the spread of the disease (as well as an all-new strain) as if it is some sort of daring sporting event. It's no wonder the majority refuses to accept us. Why would they? I say, close down the baths and the sex parties. What have we done to deserve them?
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
#25

The Normal Heart nailed in in April of 1985

The internet "dating" sites are the new bath houses and bars. It's easier than ever to hook up and have sex with someone who you know absolutely nothing about other than what they have written. There's even "home delivery" for those who don't want to travel. And, age or image is not a variable here Auggie. I've run into a few very kinky boy-next-door type accountants who've adopted a kid and belong to the PTA.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $70
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $101