a darkly beautiful "Million Dollar Baby" — Page 2

I'm thinking about seeing this movie today.

Is it violent?

---

EvelynNesbit1906 - "I'd rather see Scorsese enjoy big success over Eastwood any day."

Why do you say that?

---

Such a beautiful film! I think this may just win Best Picture. And, I agree that Hilary is deserving of an Oscar for it--as are Eastwood (in 3 or 4!? categories) and Freeman. And, as has been said--there are some great performances by theatre folk.

If people dislike the film, than it is imHo because they want it to be a typical film--and it is anything but. How refreshing to see a film completely challenge preconceived notions of a "boxing movie".

---

This movie was EXCELLENT. "The Aviator" is still my #1 pick, but "Baby" is pretty damn close. Powerful stuff.

Darn that Hilary Swank. Just when I thought no performance deserved an Oscar more than Imelda Staunton I had to go see Million Dollar Baby. Let me just say that if Staunton does not win (and I believe she still has the edge) there has not been a year in recent history when a tie would be more appropriate.

Swank is a marvel. I thought that the pairing of actress/role in Boys Don't Cry was one of those magical moments that happen once in a career. Not so. It was no fluke.

I have never been a huge Eastwood fan, but this is by far his best work ever as a director and certainly the best-acted role of his career. And is it just me, or did he look a lot like Paul Newman?

And it nice to see Morgan Freeman is a part worthy of his talent as opposed to the crap he has been doing the last few years.

I was very moved by the themes of Family and Forgiveness. What a sad, sad film.

I did have some problems with the subplot involving "Danger", the young mentally challenged kid who hangs out at the gym. It seemed a bit fragmented and I thought there must be some scenes that didn't make the final cut that could have clarified his relationships and tie him in thematically a bit more.

---

I think Danger presents a beautiful antithesis to Swank's character.

---

I saw it again the other day and was just as moved.
I laughed out loud (the priest cracked me up) and the nuanced performance by Freeman deserves an Oscar nod.
I'm not a fan of boxing movies, but this really isn't a boxing movie, which suprised me even more.
Poorly marketed movie. It reminds me of Shawshank. It will be a movie that few see in the theaters, it will win a bunch of awards and then people will watch it on video and say "I can't believe I never saw this in the theater"

My wife did not want to see it & she agrees with me it was great

If this does not win Best Picture & Mr Moore's opus does I will hurl

---

This just opened near me, so I saw it tonight. What a spectacular film. My favorite of this year (or last year, rather). The acting was simple, but very effective (the relationship between Eastwood and Swank has gotten a lot of adoration, but Freeman and Eastwood work wonderfully together as well, and even the little time devoted to Swank and Freeman together are great). The screenplay was hilarious, tear-jerking, and depressing, without being overly melodramatic. The score was Oscar-worthy (a shame that paperwork cost it a nod), and the lighting was beautiful. It's amazing that Eastwood is still making films of this quality. I recommend it wholeheartedly. Get out and see it!

I saw it a 2nd time this weekend, and found it even more satisfying. I posted elsewhere that, whatever the Oscars, it will become a classic in a way The Aviator may not. It's just such a distinctly American story -- classic themes that run through our literature and movies.

And Sueleen, you made me tear up, writing about the father/daughter wedding metaphr. How perfect and apt. What's remarkable about he movie is how pure of heart is is -- a phrase you rarely get to use. Can you imagine how many people would've turned this into something else? A May-December thing? It's an extraordinary love story because it's familial and not romantic. It took my breath away, twice (I started this thread in mid-December) and tonight I was thrilled indeed to read that Eastwood won the DGA.

---

I was thrilled to hear Eastwood got the best diector nod from the DGA yesterday. I don't know what the oscars outcome will be. But one thing for sure; this movie will be a classic.

---

Loved it. I'm on a run of seeing all the best picture nominees, which is a bit difficult where I live. Saw this the day after The Aviator. Both were wonderful.

Uplifting?