This took some time...I think its proper to mention the particular production of each show that landed it on my list.
1. Hairspray (any company, any time, anywhere)
2. Chicago (with Bebe)
3. Avenue Q (with orig. cast)
4. The Who's Tommy (1st. Nat. tour in Boston circa 1994)
5. Cats (Bway circa 1992 and London 1999)
6. Godspell (Never seen a good production, but the orig. must have been amazing)
7. Hair (North Shore Music Theatre 1999-ish)
8. The Phantom of the Opera (Any time, anywhere)
9. You're A Good Man Charlie Brown (1999 revival)
10. Carousel (1996 in Boston with Patrick Wilson and Sarah Uriarte Berry)
"Y'all have a GRAND day now"