Your statement is quite silly, Broadwaybaby6. The original stars were only together in the show for about 8 months or so (the show opened at the end of July 1975 and then half the cast left around April '76 to head up the LA company and the whole group never all performed together again) yet the show continued to thrill and dazzle audiences for another 14 years (and beyond that on tour). You make it sound like the show doesn't work without the original cast which is ludicrous given the incredibly short amount of time they were together and how many brilliant casts of the show there were after their 8 months (not counting the run at the Public).
I saw the original cast of ACL back in 1976 and returned to the Shubert Theatre over a half dozen times after that and found the show to be electrifying every single time -- and I saw several replacement casts that were even more powerful and dynamic than the originals were. THAT'S why it's one of the most successful shows in the history of theatre -- ANY cast of first rate dancer/singers can re-create the magic of the show. It is completetly unreliant on stars or the original cast. And frankly, other than maybe McKechnie and perhaps Kelly Bishop, I wouldn't call any of the original cast the definitive interpreters of their roles. While yes, they were present at the creation and part of it with their stories, and yes there was something special and different about them from any other cast, the fact is that in the past 30 years I've seen better performances in each of those roles. I've seen several far more talented Dianas, Richies, Pauls and Vals than Lopez, Dennis, Williams and Blair and had many magical nights with this show since the orignal cast left (I've seen the show about a dozen times between the Shubert, national tours and regional productions).
As long as Bennett's genius shines through -- and I'm so GLAD that they're recreating one of the most briilliant pieces of staging in the history of Broadway; there's too much energy and electricity in it for it to ever feel like a museum piece -- I think it'll do very well with the critics and I think that a new generation is going to discover this show and it should do fine at the box office. I don't expect another 15 year run, but it'll recoup.
"What a story........ everything but the bloodhounds snappin' at her rear end." -- Birdie
[http://margochanning.broadwayworld.com/]
"The Devil Be Hittin' Me" -- Whitney
Updated On: 6/13/06 at 02:45 PM