Fosse -
"I thought the gay subplot in the second act was not only unecessary, but a complete rip-off of Victor Victoria, not to mention a bit offensive in that it treats homosexuality as something to laugh at."
Hold on one second! Thats not what that was at all....
First of all, calling it a rip off Victor/Victoria is incorrect. Sure they are similar, but All Shook Up is a "rip off" of the Shakespeare comedies. That whole idea of a man falling in love with a woman who is dressed as a man is in both Twelfth Night AND As You Like It.
Second of all, This show doesn't treat homosexuality as something to laugh at any more than Shakespeare or Victor/Victoria (using your example) and no one seems to have a problem with it in those shows.
Also what needs to be remembered is this - All Shook Up is set in "a small you-never-heard-of-it town some where in the Midwest" in 1955. Even though it was released in 2005, All Shook Up is set 50 years ago - a time when homosexuality was not accepted. Honestly, how weird would it have been in the context of the show if Chad's love of Ed had been accepted by everyone in the town.
In short - All Shook Up is far from making fun of homosexuality. If you dont like the show, thats fine, but please don't back up your stance with falsely accusing a show of portraying homosexuality as something to laugh at.
Updated On: 4/28/05 at 08:39 PM