Andy Karl Question

Andy Karl has gotten excellent reviews and Tony nominations for his last two roles in "Ground Hog Day" and "Rocky". Unfortunately, both of these shows will be considered flops. I was wondering if the commercial failure of these two shows will hurt him in the future for getting new roles on Broadway. I would think his excellent performances would be the main factor but did not know if actor needed to also be in successful shows also.

yankeefan7 said: "Andy Karl has gotten excellent reviews and Tony nominations for his last two roles in "Ground Hog Day" and "Rocky". Unfortunately, both of these shows will be considered flops. I was wondering if the commercial failure of these two shows will hurt him in the future for getting new roles on Broadway. I would think his excellent performances would be the main factor but did not know if actor needed to also be in successful shows also.



"

Just my opinion (and I'm certainly not an expert), but neither Rocky nor GHD have really tried to bill Andy as the solo/celebrity draw. I mean, he's certainly a lead and is on all the marketing, but it's not like he's being billed like Glenn Close in Sunset Boulevard. (Yes, I'm aware the marketing for Groundhog Day does highlight his Olivier win).

I'm hoping the lack of financial success doesn't reflect on him and he continues to get good roles - he's extremely talented, puts an incredible amount into his roles, and is very kind to his fans.

I can see it having an effect on what he's offered, which is very disappointing. I just hope the first call he gets after GHD isn't from Wicked asking him to come back as Fiyero, because that would be adding insult to insult and injury. Nothing against Wicked, he's just moved beyond it. And is too old.

After this, I could see him taking a break from the stage. Hopefully he'll get another TV opportunity like Law & Order. Although, I'd really like to see him in a straight play.

Updated On: 7/18/17 at 01:42 PM

Oh he'll get his Tony when he plays Nathan Detroit in the next revival of Guys & Dolls or some other revival. he's getting to old to appear in new productions especially when it's bad material so his best chances are in a revival.

froote said: "Too old to appear in new productions? You do realize that new productions have older characters too?"

Case in point: Rachel Bay Jones - 2017 Tony Award Winner for Dear Evan Hansen.

Updated On: 7/18/17 at 02:40 PM

Coincidentally, Andy signed with ICM today. From the article: "Look for ICM to urge him further into work in film and television."

Whatever happens, I hope he finds work that he enjoys and showcases his talent.

If anyone needed proof GROUNDHOG DAY is dunzo...



http://deadline.com/2017/07/groundhog-day-star-andy-karl-signs-with-icm-partners-1202130923/

I really enjoyed his run on SVU. It was the first I'd ever seen/heard of him. Having been a fan of the show for several years, I was actually disappointed with his character when it was introduced - just not my 'type' of guy - but the heart and soul he displayed completely won me over and I was in complete tears at his finale episode (won't spoil it in case someone hasn't seen it).

I wouldn't be disappointed to have him do more TV, but I'd be disappointed if it was a move he was 'forced' into for lack of success on stage... I mean, audiences love him, he's been pretty steadily cast, and he has 3 tony noms and an Olivier win - if that's not success...!

Margo319 said: "That's ridiculous. So, he signs with a place that does "Television; Motion Pictures; Concerts; Publishing; Theater; Branded Entertainment; Production Arts · Broadcasting" and Groundhog Day is done? Stupid.



"

Did you not read the end of the article?

"Look for ICM to urge him further into work in film and television."

Updated On: 7/19/17 at 07:16 AM

I thought "Groundhog Day" would reopen in the West End, and perhaps Andy Karl would star in that London production as well? Seemed better received in the UK and I think operating costs are a third of weekly costs in the USA. Seems to me the play could have done with less flash and costly production numbers and gone over even better as the songs and performances are so strong. Various promotional performances of Barrett and Karl seems to me more engaging and intimate than the full scale production. Showcases some of the songs better.