The Book of Mormon
Hamilton
The Band's Visit
Dear Evan Hansen
Once
Fun Home
Gentleman's Guide
Kinky Boots
Memphis
That being said, I genuinely love all nine of these shows and ranking them was really hard!
Hamilton.
It's my favorite because a cast recording never captured me the way this one did. I'd listen over and over discovering a new layer and a new meaning to the lyrics. How something I never saw with my eyes could connect me and make me cry. The use of layering lyrics of a song, combined in a kind of harmony (Schuyler Sisters and Non-Stop) forgive me for not knowing the technical name for this, I just loved hearing it and how one could zone in on one character in the song and listen to what were saying. When I saw it staged and how with minimal props and scenery, I could visualize everything that was being told. The Bullet! And how she was pretty much used as the omen of death with who she came in contact with. How much I learned about a topic I never thought I'd be interested in! How it made me feel proud as a latina to have Lin-Manuel, someone from my neck of the woods--be so influential and create this wonderful show. So influential, I have two part time jobs now: one in theater and one at the bank!
Without Band's Visit (hoping to see this month):
1. Dear Evan Hansen
2. Book of Mormon
3. Once
4. Gentleman's Guide
5. Kinky Boots
6. Fun Home
7. Hamilton
8. Memphis
Newsies, Matilda, American in Paris, Come From Away, and Great Comet would be higher than most of these if they had won
Broadway Legend Joined: 10/18/17
I love Memphis. Seen twice actually. I want to see Dear Evan Hansen more than Hamilton
Featured Actor Joined: 9/26/15
1. Hamilton
2. Fun Home
3. Dear Evan Hansen
4. Book of Mormon
5. Kinky Boots
HUGE GAP
6. Band's Visit
7. Once
(haven't seen GGLAM or Memphis so can't speak for those ones)
My favorites (which is not necessarily synonymous with "best":
1. Hamilton
2. Gentleman's Guide
3. Billy Elliot
4. Once
5. The Band's Visit
6. Fun Home
7. Book of Morrmon
8. Memphis
9. Kinky Boots
10. Dear Evan Hansen
The first 7 I considered worthy of the award.
Stand-by Joined: 12/8/17
1. HAMILTON
2. DEAR EVAN HANSEN
3. THE BAND'S VISIT
4. BOOK OF MORMON
5. FUN HOME
6. GENTLEMAN'S GUIDE
(drop off)
7. KINKY BOOTS
8. MEMPHIS
9. ONCE
And dammit I wish Come From Away could've tied with DEH.
hamilton is probably the best best musical since at least the producers if not a chorus line
1. Fun Home
2. Kinky Boots
3. Hamilton
4. Once
<—— insert “Waitress” here
5. Dear Evan Hansen
6. The Book of Mormon
<——insert “Bright Star” then “The Great Comet” here
7. The Band’s Visit
<—- maybe a lot more nominated musicals here like Come from Away, Shuffle Along etc.
8. Gentleman’s Guide
<—- maybe a lot more musicals not even nominated for a Tony here
9. Memphis
Videos