I braved the storm tonight to see this and it is by far one of my favorite things of the season. That's not to say that I didn't have issues with it (I did), but what's good is so wonderful that I almost feel guilty complaining.
Instead of giving Kelli some grand entrance, Bartlett has her slowly wander onto the dimly lit stage until she finds herself downstage, bathed in a soft, white glow. She begins to sing the stunning opening number and I am completely overwhelmed by how good she sounds. It's not like this is her Broadway debut and we've never heard her sing before, but it's genuinely shocking to hear someone sing so well. She is absolute perfection throughout the show, not just vocally. She acts the sh!t out of the role and scores several big laughs too. Her Francesca is so warm and lovely.
JRB so clearly gets the characters of Francesca and Robert too; both of their songs contain some of his best lyrics he's ever written. Their melodies are lush and romantic. The orchestrations, also done by JRB, are excellent.
Steven Pasquale really comes into his own too. He's in great voice and has smoldering chemistry with Kelli. I haven't been so invested in the happiness of two characters since I can't remember when. Their duet "Before and After You/One Second & a Million Miles" was so good! It's stuff like this that will keep me going back to the theater again and again.
There have been comments that Kelli and Steven are two young, but I disagree. Yes they are younger than Meryl and Eastwood, but if they wanted to replicate the movie they would have cast Keith Carradine and Karen Ziemba.
The problem with the show isn't so much the length, but that I didn't care about any of the other characters, save Cass Morgan, and when the focus shifted to the supporting characters I couldn't wait for it to shift back to the main attraction.
They really, really need to cut the scene at the State Fair that begins act two. It won't be missed and feels like filler. Just start with the following scene of Kelli and Steven in bed together.
I had a negative reaction to the performances of the two children. They both really need to tone it done, especially next to the highly naturalistic performances coming from the two leads. Klena and Kinnunen are grating and obnoxious. Maybe they're trying to feel out the roles, but it's too much right now. The conflict between Klena and Hunter Foster is underdeveloped, but I didn't care about it and I would rather see it dropped than developed further.
I think the problems are easily fixable: cut about 20-25 minutes of the fat and this could really be a special show. I will 100% be going back several times during previews.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!