I'm keeping my fingers and toes crossed that Xanadu survives the bleak months. Should it weather that storm, it may well have a chance at a Tony nomination for Best Musical and, with that, national TV exposure (hope they do a better job than on the Thanksgiving parade). Looking at its competition, my speculations at this point are:
1. Young Frankenstein: Aside from the disappointing reviews, I think too many people are offended by the ticket prices and just fed up with the whole thing. Like so many follow-up shows that didn't live up to their predecessor, I think an over-reaction set in. Only if the other shows are down-and-out disasters will YF be nominated.
2. Little Mermaid: Terrible reviews, although the show will run in true Disney-like fashion. Frankly, I'd think they'd be hesitant to go on national TV -- it would just pound one more nail into the coffin.
3. In the Heights: Although they got nice enough reviews Off-Broadway last year, they weren't raves that had everyone scurrying to the box office. IMO, should have moved to another Off-Broadway house. However, the others will have to go a long distance to beat this one for Best Choreography.
4. Cry-Baby: Seems to be the one to watch, based on out-of-town reviews and word of mouth.
5. Catered Affair: IMO, this will be either an unmitigated disaster or a sleeper hit.
6. Passing Strange: Although well-received critically, this may be a little too esoteric for general consumption.
So, not having seen all the shows yet and caveats aside, IMO the nominated shows will be:
1. Cry-Baby
2. Catered Affair
3. Xanadu
4. Passing Strange or In the Heights.
BroadwayEd