"The Lyric should be used for concerts or special shows only. It is simply to big to make a Broadway show have any chance of succeeding.
Wait wait wait, your saying is too large for a show to succeed. Then how do you explain wicked which is in the Gershwin and is even larger? I think the theatre should fit with the size of the production. So I don't think the lyric should be used for concerts or special shows."
I'm really glad so many new shows have made it into the million dollar 'club'! Something Rotten, The King and I (well, revival), An American In Paris, Finding Neverland..bravo!
Also - this is just my opinion, I LOVE Wicked but say it opened 2 years ago, last year, this year, what have you - in the Gershwin (or, the Lyric, or the Broadway) I don't think it would be such a success today with this economy. I don't think many shows these days last long in the bigger theaters, no matter how great the production is. I mean, look how many shows have gone in and out of the Broadway the past few years (Shrek, Promises Promises, Sister Act, Cinderella, Dr. Zhivago). I'm not saying they were all incredible, but, I think if they had been in smaller theaters then some would have definitely had a longer life.