I saw Carousel yesterday (matinee)...picked up a rush ticket about 1130am. I might have been the last one--house looked sold out. Seat was fine. Row B rear Mezz.
I loved the show--such a classic. Although my degrees are in music and I taught it for years, I don't have the knowledge that many of you have here, so kindly indulge my opinion.
There needed to be more intimacy between Jessie and Joshua. If they were more physical from the beginning, I would have found their relationship more believable. Jessie's voice is just lovely; perfect for the part and Joshua's Soliloquy got the most applause of the entire show. The dancing was wonderful--it's a pleasure that the dance numbers weren't cut. The ballet was beautiful. The two songs that several of you mentioned were cut were not in my Playbill, so I didn't miss them. Renee Fleming was one of the reasons I went. I go the Met as much as Broadway, so I'm used to quality singing. I (and most around me) were tearing up....lots of sniffling when she sang "You'll Never Walk Alone". I'd never heard the lyric "chin held high"--I thought it was "head held high".
The presence of the Starkeeper walking around the stage during Act 1 confused a lot of people. I wasn't thrilled with that staging, nor was I with the costumes of those in heaven. The other costumes were right on target. It was great hearing a large (by Broadway standards) orchestra, though it was a bit over amplified for me. Just a few other things: The Carousel Waltz should have been a bigger number; with the quality of the dancing throughout, I wanted this to soar along with the orchestra. I'm glad the producers/director didn't change the show due to the MeToo movement; the work speaks for itself. The one line that I found most timely was when Mr. Bascomb said he was glad he decided to carry a gun for once. Bet the NRA loved that one. Finally, I was offended when I overhead several audience members making what I considered racist remarks about the casting.