Well that was a unique night of theater in LA-- an actual homegrown production of a show few have ever seen that has just reopened (with most of the original cast) in a purpose-built thrust staging plopped right in the middle of the auditorium of the Los Angeles Theater-- one of those fabulous movie-palaces that still light up the Broadway corridor downtown. And for context, I've never seen the musical CARRIE in any staging till now, so I'm a total newbie to the show.
Wow, that's one damn hard show to pull off well! The requirements of soaring vocals, a cast who must be believable as high-schoolers, the telekinesis, the stunt flying, the camp, the kitsch, the crucifix (with a choreographed Jesus!), the pig blood, the mass-murders, and the fiery inferno. And somehow they had to squeeze all of this on to an even smaller playing space than normal since the gym-floor acting area was being constantly shrunk by the rearranging of rolling audience bleachers. Did director Brady Schwind and his intrepid cast succeed? Well it's a mixed score from me, though my husband loved the thing with few reservations.
My loudest cheers go to the high-powered cast, for somehow making the crazy nonsense seem legitimate and stage-worthy. My top favorite was easily Jenell Lynn Randall's sympathetic gym teacher Miss Gardner. Great stage presence, great voice in "Unsuspecting Hearts". Knew how to bring humanity to all the cartoons around her. Emily Lopez was an interesting UN-fragile Carrie, with a pop-music belt that surprised me. (Would that really be how Carrie sounds inside her own mind? Who knew?). Misty Cotton seemed far too young for Margaret White (Carrie appeared to be her younger sister), but her voice was strong and she kept the unwanted laughs to a minimum, which is the best one can hope during those insane scenes. The boys? Well, for such underwritten parts, they were cute, I guess. But high marks to Jon Robert Hall for making "You Shine" with Kayla Parker my favorite number in the show.
Also on the plus side, the telekinetic magic was always a simple surprise that served the show well. The aerial stunt work was superb-- wish there were a lot more of it. Those rolling bleachers? Well we had friends in those seats who said that the moment when Carrie appears to move the bleachers with her mind was thrilling, but the repeated rolling around got old fast. (Save the extra $80 and stick to a stationary spot on the "Junior" bleachers instead.)
Design-wise there's a LOT of scenery here, if you count the entire bleacher structure created for the show. I wish there had been more that was visually evocative before getting to the prom itself -- lots of eye fatigue staring at abstract colored bands projected on black scrims that surround the space. I was not a fan of the lighting, sadly. Really tough to see faces amidst the colored slashes shooting this way and that. And I could embrace the contemporary costume choices for the cast (even though my images of CARRIE are all connected to the 70's disco era), so what's with the hippie clothes that Carrie and Margaret are both saddled with? Shouldn't Margaret be clothed more conservatively than a latter-day Joni Mitchell?
Bottom line, the creators of the show have given an almost impossibly tough challenge to any cast and crew trying to make sense of the daft script and score here. To the extent that this company makes it damn close to a good night of theater, I gotta salute them. Head downtown to see what they're doing so you too can be part of the conversation.
Updated On: 10/4/15 at 02:47 PM