Florence and Anatoly don't meet until MOUNTAIN DUET. It's an instant attraction...which is fine, but weak when you have these large, complex actions going on.
The trouble with discussing CHESS is that there are so many recorded and unrecorded versions of the show, each with their own plot. My favorite is the original release of the DANISH TOUR. It is rather complete. And logically places PITY THE CHILD right at Freddie's breakdown, so we feel sympathy - or empathy - for him throughout the rest of the show.
I don't think the song is strong enough, or rather Freddie is not likeable enough, for the song to be a redemption song at the end of the show.
The shows biggest problem is focus. People always complain when major characters are introduced late in the show. Svetlana comes in so late, it's a pity.
But then we have Florence and Freddie to begin with. Then Anatoly comes in. ACT I closes with Anatoly singing the big song. So the natural thing to think is the show will continue with Anatoly, and the effects of his decision.
Then Freddie comes back and starts making some more Or is the point you aren't on anyone's side? I've always felt most for Florence, especially with the father subplot that is always awkwardly pushed.
LES MISERABLES is smart, because it follows Valjean. Yes, it occasionally goes off on a tangent, but always returns to Valjean.
I think Chess would benefit if it follows Florence, who is at the heart of everything - the love triangle, East/West Relations, her father...not to mention, she's an extremely interesting character. In that case, ANTHEM needs to revolve around Anatoly going to Florence, among many other things.
ETA: Just read siren's post above mine, which is very interesting re: Anatoly. And I just want to add that these can all be achieved, while still focusing on the particular struggle of one character. I didn't mean to say it is all about Florence...or all about Anatoly...but that there needs to be a through-line to take us from Act I, Scene I to the final scene of the show.
Updated On: 2/13/07 at 10:11 PM