I vote for In My Life, but I actually really enjoyed it. Yes, it was bad, but it was still an original show, which, in comparison to half of what's running, makes it worth a little.
Carrie springs to mind very quickly as well...Buckley and Hateley though, not Cook (Or as it should be termed "And Barbara Was Weak") I wouldn't have minded a La Cage recording IF Bryan Batt had been Albin instead of Beach.
http://www.youtube.com/huskcharmer