I guess I'll throw in my dissenting opinion here, but I saw the matinee performance the day before the show opened, and saw Hydzik. He had a very pleasant voice, and it may be the direction, or the production itself, but his acting seemed to be too one-note, and on the same level. There was not a large depth to his emotions throughout the entire piece. He gave the same emotion when talking to Doc who tells him that Maria is "dead," as when he was talking to Riff at the beginning of Act I.
What also might be a fault of the production itself, was the chemistry between him and Maria. It felt like one of those "let's go on a date to the movies and see where it goes" instead of true love at first sight that truly cannot be explained.
-There's the muddle in the middle. There's the puddle where the poodle did the piddle."