I'm actually really liking the Conan O'Brien idea.
haha, it would never happen.
However, Conan can actually sing. He usually jokes around when ever he does it, but if he dropped the act and sang I am sure he would sound great.
what about Harry Connick Jr.?
o0o...I never ever would have thought of Donny as Corny..but now that the idea is in my head, it seems like an amazing fit!
as the originator of the donny as corny idea i still stand by it. another idea, just for kicks HASSELHOFF
Broadway Star Joined: 11/13/05
Harry Connick Jr. turns everything into a Jazz number. If he refrained from doing this...I wouldn't mind.
But Donny Osmond...that's different. I kinda like it.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/20/04
I like the suggestions of Osmond and O'Brian. Conan would be hilarious, I think.
I can also see David Hasselhoff working in the role.
my official list, in order
donny osmond
david hasselhoff
paul rudd (he minimally harmonizes well, based off anchorman and the 40 yr old virgin)
steve carrell
carson daly
I am totally LOVING the idea for Conan O'Brien as Corny.
donny - yes, ok.
david- the movie would be laughed at more than it already is getting.
Paul- not horrible, it would be something new for him and everyone else.
Steve- I dont think so. His look is all wrong.
Carson-?? Just because he is a talk show host does not make him a good candidate... can he act (aside from daria voiceovers) OR sing?
A Broadway name? Are you kidding?
Corny Collins is the one role where they can get away with casting ANYONE. Donald Trump could do this role and get away with it.
They aren't looking at Norbert Leo Butz. They are only seeing A-list and B-list Hollywood names. They would love to have a Regis Phiban or Ryan Seacrest or Dick Clark. But they would also love to have like a George Clooney do it and make a fool outta himself.
What about Steve Martin? Hasn't he been in a lot of the director's movies?
yeh he has, but CC even though is a nice sized role is not big enough for steve. (i imagine)
plus i guess i see CC in his 30's.
Broadway Legend Joined: 12/31/69
If age isn't a factor, I think someone like David Bowie could be just quirky enough to work.
I'm interested in the Harry Connick Jr. idea.
Same Here, HCJ and Donny seem great.
Harry Conick? I can totally picture that.
I love the idea of Donny playing Corny, although i also think Ewan MacGregor could do it very well
I like the Conan idea.
I also think Sean Hayes would be good.
Did you guys all forget that Corny has to sing? And not just a little bit.
Conan????
Ryan Seacrest????
Regis?
*head slap*
Are you kidding?
Of course they could always CUT his songs or dub him... if that's really what you want.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/15/03
I'd like to see Eric McCormack so Corny Collins.
Heck, I'd like to see Eric McCormack do anything!
best12bars- well at least regis sings reasonably well, he recorded a christmas cd that wasn't too bad
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/29/04
I think they could easily cast Clarke Thorell or Troy Britton Johnson as Corny. They're relative unknowns to everyone outside of the Broadway microcosm, and even inside, those two aren't necessarily huge names. Both did fantastic on the separate occasions that I saw them perform, and I think bringing someone from the Broadway or tour cast wouldn't be too horrible, since Corny isn't necessarily a gigantic part.
Of course, I'm fine with Hugh or Donny. No problem there.
I'm glad we're leaving the casting to casting directors ... and not the people who post on this board...
Videos