NYCbabe, can I ask you something? Have you even seen "Wonderful Town"? Because every time I see your posts you claim that Donna's role isn't as "demanding" or "complex" as some of the other roles. I beg to differ!!
The physicality of the part is one thing; add the comedic timing necassary as well; on top of that, there are all the different types of music she sings; and the tender, moving moments to top it all off. How can you say that it's not demanding? Please, "Conga" alone should win her the award.
I, too, think Donna would have won even without the "Wicked" women cancelling each other out, which I don't think happened anayway. She gives a great performance and she desreves every accolade she gets for it, period. Don't diminish her achievements just because your favorite performer didn't win.
Oh, and I've also seen both Eden and Idina, and I agree with the opinion expressed that Eden was just as good in the acting department, which is what the award is really about. Vocally, of course, Idina is amazing- but I don't think that it's the issue. The awards are given for the overall performance.
"Years from now, when you talk about this - And you will - Be kind. "