OK, I think my remarks about Beyoncé’s singing voice as a soloist or member of Destiny’s Child were slightly misconstrued. To me, Beyoncé’s performance on the subject soundtrack was spot-on and well within character. It’s on her personal studio projects that she and the current crop of pop/rnb-lite singers just don’t meet my muster. On much of her solo work, I still find Beyoncé’s singing voice shrill, sharp, monotonous and cookie-cutter. To her credit, she really delivered on ‘Dangerously In Love’ and ‘Listen’ which I’m calling a masterpiece to anyone willing to listen. And no one has ever accused Diana Ross of being a vocal powerhouse but the lady has always been a song stylist/interpreter-extraordinaire capable of thoroughly engaging an audience and giving a first-rate interview.
I’d also like to remind this audience that Diana Ross entered the business prior to the advent of the present-day ubiquitous cable video complex which I always use as the line of demarcation in any discussion about recording artists of today versus yesteryear. Heck yeah I tend to defend my era because the legacy acts then had to sell the product the hard way, by radio and a kick-azz road show. Today, some acts, especially the young ladies, simply have to be eye candy, lay some Pro-Tools assisted vocal tracks produced by some egomaniacal blinged-out producer who changes his name every 3 months, pay friends for adds on the web space that dare not be mentioned on here, pay “pitchers” who in turn DJ’s & station programmers for radio spins, lip sync through a video directed by hot-producer-du-jour and BAM. There barrier to entry in show business is substantially lower today than it was for Diana Ross since she’s been put out that as an example. I’m just not quite ready to declare Beyoncé this generation’s Diana Ross in terms of her artistry as a soloist and the dues she’s paid to make her mark in the business. She’s on course though.
#FactsMatter...your feelings not so much.
Updated On: 12/7/06 at 04:03 PM