Just came back from seeing the show tonight. I liked the score and how it kinda all washed over me. "Sun and Shade" and "Miro" were a couple of standouts. For me, who was never really into Kelli O'Hara before, I though she gave a ravishing performance. She was quite lovely and radiant (and now fairly obviously pregnant, especially when she is wearing her overcoat). Stephen Pasquale was fine, but I think the material does make him a bit too harsh and abrasive. From the first scene he comes in on, you knew that Cathy would be leaving him by the end of the show, knowing the movie or not. I do think I enjoyed the show more knowing just the basic plot line, but never really having watched the movie and having all the knowledge of Sirk styled movies. I also thought Nancy Anderson's "BFF" character was a little too grating and needling. And the maid really needed a number or two with Cathy (though you would have to cut something, because the show seemed like the perfect length as is now).
The set was a little ugly, but serviceable for the space and budget, so I didn't mind it as much.
Xanadu! Can't cry on cue!