LizzieCurry said: "How different was Nicole? I already have tickets for next month, but did lotto a few times this week since she was on.
I'm planning on seeing the tour in Chicago, but I need at least one more viewing of the Broadway staging!
I felt she was more detached, than Ms. Malone, as she moved around the stage, watching the proceedings. I don't ever recall forgetting that Ms. Malone was there, observing (and that works, wonderfully), but Ms. Van Giesen, sometimes blended into the scenery and became an observer, with the audience. It was probably not something noticeable if it was a first viewing, but it was very effective, for me.
For some reason, her Telephone Wire was even more memorable, but I have yet to put a finger on, exactly why. She has a lovely voice, btw.
Overall, I think it's a more subtle take on the role and just as effective and heartbreaking, when she shifts from observer to active participant.
If you see Ms. Van Giesen, I doubt you will be disappointed.