I loved it and thought the score was terrific. Saw it twice with Jordan, once with Morrison and once with Morrison's understudy. I thought all gave fine performances, but enjoyed Morrison's the most, even if for the wrong reason. Jordan was terrific in all ways but his basic movement, which was rigid. Morrison was fluid -- you wanted him to break out into a Fred Astaire homage -- but the wasn't necessarily Barrie.
i have listened to many of last season's cast recordings and I will never understand the rancor concerning this score...I really think it has a lot of terrific songs.
Ironically, in the old days, 600 performances would have been a more than respectable run and likely resulted in a profitable run. Not any more.