The show tryed out at Vassar the summer before it hit Broadway. Justin Guarini was the "featured" cast member, who left prior to Broadway. I didn't see it, so I can't speak for that production.
There were numerous, numerous problems with the Broadway version. They were in the process of doing rewrites and whatnot when I believe they got an ultimatum from the Beach Boys catelogue's rights holders, "produce the show by December ___ or lose the rights." (That could have been a rumor). The show started previews in early December of December in advance of a mid-January opening. It finally opened in early February, only to close in April.
The show was an absolute trainwreck. The voices and acting were subpar, with Jessica-Snow Wilson and Titus Burgess in strong supporting roles giving the most dynamic performances.
Many compared the show to a high school performance and I can't say they were wrong. Storylines were dropped throughout previews, characters were added and deleted (there was a bizarre day-long subplot about an alien landing). A show doctor was brought in (I forget whom) but it didn't help. There was too much that needed to be fixed.
There were a variety of endings (none of which worked), the final one being a giant sing along on surfboards and beachballs tossed into the audience. There were a variety of plotlines for the character of Rhonda (played by now Law and Order star Milena Govich), with her starting off as a car mechanic and ending as a waitress (I believe). John Carrafa couldn't direct wind, let alone direct AND choreograph a show like Good Vibrations.
Carrafa would greet preview audiences with "Please remember this is a work in progress, NOT the finished product, so if a trainwreck happens, we'll pause to fix things."
I guess he doesn't know what a trainwreck looks like.
Updated On: 2/1/07 at 04:57 PM