Rainah said: "Disappointed with Reeve as Orpheus - he had a lot of trouble with the score in Edmonton and I didn't like the direction they took the character with his casting. More dusty, down-on-his-luck, but nice guy, rather than the charismatic, genuine, but a little bit of devil-may-care I got off the live cast recording. And his voice, imo, is nowhere close to the gorgeous bell-like quality of Damon's that really sells Orpheus as someone with a true gift.
That being said, happy with a new direction for Hermes, that element always felt like it wasn't quite working on the same level as some of the other characters. And Eva is an exciting development (though I've not had an issue with any of the past Eurydices) and glad to see Amber and Patrick confirmed."
Doesn't matter who plays him, Orpheus is the most bland, boring character in the show. At least he was at NYTW.