I saw the show on Saturday with my daughter (our second time, as I saw almost all of the original cast last year, sans Lin and Oak, in New York City). I had better seats this time, center orchestra in Row P, and noticed little things (hand movements by the dancers, facial expressions) that were hard to see from the rafters at the Richard Rodgers.
I went into the show determined not to compare the touring cast, at the beginning of their second week performing together, with the Broadway cast that had been together for well over a year. But the comparisons were tough to avoid, in part because seeing Hamilton with a new cast, who have varying levels of experience in the show and approach their roles a differently, does alter it in noticeable ways. For someone seeing it for the first time, I doubt this would affect their experience. The company is excellent, the music sounds the same (a legitimate concern given the much larger size of the Orpheum). It's the same, outstanding show.
The first thing that seemed different from the outset is that Aaron Burr dominates the show even more than on Broadway. My daughter and I both said after the show that it could easily have been called, "Burr." Leslie Odom Jr. played Burr as tightly-controlled, cautious and guarded - and therefore a bit untrustworthy - even in lighter scenes. He exuded intelligence, but was surrounded by other geniuses and knew it. Joshua Henry is a more relaxed Burr. He's more charming and seems smarter than everyone else on stage, even Hamilton and especially Jefferson. As someone else commented, your eyes just naturally follow him, even when he's quiet. I have seen Henry once before, in Shuffle Along on Broadway, and recall reading gripes that he didn't get a big song of his own in that show. And now I understand the complaints. He nails Burr's big songs, along with the underrated "Dear Theodosia" and his part of the final duel. His "The Room Where it Happens" showstopper really does stop the show, and got the biggest ovation of the night by far. I'm still partial to Odom's version, which was my favorite all-time moment at a musical, but Henry is outstanding. I doubt I will see two Burrs as good as Odom Jr. and Henry.
Henry can hardly be faulted for being so good, but his presence does tip the scales in the show. By making Burr even more captivating and sympathetic, he becomes the tragic hero of the musical in a way that even Odom - who played Burr colder - did not.
This creates some issues. Michael Luwoye isn't bad as Hamilton and makes some interesting choices to play him as an angry, young man. His retorts in the Cabinet Battles, especially in the second one, are less mocking than infuriated. He gets right in Jefferson's face, yelling at him. Luwoye makes for a less charming Hamilton overall, though he does well in "Farmer Refuted," a song that always works better in person. He is a good rapper with a powerful singing voice, which shows up nicely in "Hurricane," but "It's Quiet Uptown" left both my daughter and I a bit cold. His interactions with the Schuyler sisters and Maria Reynolds don't have the snap to them that they should, although in fairness, his interactions with all three actresses are probably a work in progress.
Emmy Raver-Lampman's unique hairstyle is very cool, and she sounded a lot like Renee Goldsberry's Angelica (remember, the look is supposed to be modern from the neck up), only without the latter's ability to maintain the vocal power during all of "Satisfied." She closes it with a flourish, though, that put her own stamp on the song.
Solea Pfeiffer got off to a weak start as Eliza, and her voice was overwhelmed by the orchestra and the backup singers during "Helpless." But then she settled in, nailing all of Eliza's ballads and ending the show beautifully. She's ridiculously young, 21 or 22, and I suspect she has a bright future either as Eliza on Broadway/London or in other musicals that show off her lovely voice.
I'm going to stick up for Amber Iman here. I'm as much in love with Jasmine Cephas Jones' voice and performance on "Say No to This" as the next guy, but Iman has a lower voice and even plays Maria a bit differently (less femme fatale, more a little disturbed). My daughter loved her take on Maria even more than I did, and we agreed that she was a total delight as Peggy. Iman made the audience laugh several times as Peggy, and she seemed to be a gifted comic actor.
Isaiah Johnson doesn't have Chris Jackson's imposing height as Washington, and he is clearly more comfortable when singing than acting as of now. (He lets Luwoye's Hamilton dominate their argument scene too much, answering too timidly at first.) But he's got a wonderful, soulful voice that brings home "One Last Time" very effectively. He's another young actor who should only get better.
Ruben Carbajal hits the ground running as John Laurens and is almost as good as Philip in the second act. He was one of my favorites and seemed like he had been playing the role for months, not days. Very impressive.
Josh Andres Rivera, an understudy playing the role for the second night, did fine as Mulligan/Madison. No mistakes.
Oh, the Lafayette/Jefferson part. The lingering memory of Daveed Diggs is difficult to escape. Jordan Donica recently played Raoul in Phantom on Broadway, but those skills don't really translate to this role. He was charming early on as Lafayette, but when the part gets impossibly hard, he struggled holding a French accent while keeping up his rap. (He held up better on the latter than the former.) As Jefferson, he got off to a good start, but he failed to walk the tricky tightrope of making the future president both ridiculous and extraordinarily intelligent. Too often, he seemed a little silly. Jefferson doesn't seem like a worthy foe of Hamilton, much less Burr. It throws off the balance of the second act.
The tendency of the show to play a bit sillier is emphasized by Rory O'Malley, who tries too hard to milk the laughs that are there when you're playing King George.
A few other notes: Some of the staging is a little different, and they move some things center stage, probably to accommodate folks in the side orchestra seats. (Example: Angelica isn't at the top of the stairs during most of her part of "Take A Break," so more people can see her.)
For all my quibbles, though, it was fascinating to see different takes on the roles, to watch actors literally improve during a show, and to see budding stars nail their parts. I'm planning to go back in a couple of months, and it will be interesting to see how the San Francisco version of Hamilton has evolved.
Updated On: 3/21/17 at 06:30 PM