About 70% of the score was recycled material, even in the original Euro production, but out of necessity once Steinman was fired from the NY production, more material was pulled out of his trunk and apparently touched up by somebody (Don Black maybe, since he got credit for additional lyrics on "Braver Than We Are"?) for inclusion.
In show order (in NY, anyway):
Overture -- "The Storm," an instrumental from Steinman's 1981 solo album
Bad for Good (theme also heard in 1984's "Nowhere Fast" for the
Streets of Fire soundtrack)
Angels Arise -- the main melody is "Song of Gotham City" in unproduced
Batman, but also incorporates a theme from "Surf's Up"
God Has Left the Building -- second half of "The Storm," though the theme is much older than that (also heard in the '77 workshop of
Neverland and in "City of the Golden Egg" from '73's
More Than You Deserve)
Original Sin -- "Original Sin" and "Total Eclipse of the Heart"
Invitation to the Ball -- "A Good Nightmare Comes So Rarely" and "Forevermore in the Night" were unreleased parts of the
Batman score, and the Invitation sequence was as is in the German production, more of "Original Sin"
Death is Such an Odd Thing -- can be heard somewhere, I think in
Confidence Man?
Braver Than We Are -- uses a theme also heard in
Confidence Man Come With Me -- has been reused for years and years, but can be dated earliest to
Neverland and
More Than You Deserve before it
Total Eclipse of the Heart -- self-explanatory
Carpe Noctem -- parts of "Come With Me," "Left in the Dark" from
Bad for Good, and a track riff from both "Good Girls Go to Heaven" and "Back into Hell" off
Bat Out of Hell II For Sarah -- dead rip-off of "Milady" from
Confidence Man When Love is Inside You -- not a Jim melody, if you've heard the David Bowie single "Little Bombardier" (oops...did I say that out loud?)
Eternity -- started life as the song "Gods" in
Neverland, then became an instrumental called "Great Boleros of Fire" that opened Meat Loaf's
Bat I tour in the Seventies
Confession of a Vampire -- with minor variations, "Objects in the Rear View Mirror May Appear Closer Than They Are"
The Ball -- a blended combo of "Original Sin," "Total Eclipse of the Heart" (and "Come With Me," in the NY production, since Crawford just had to have a dramatic death scene)
Dance of the Vampires -- "Tonight Is What It Means to Be Young" full-stop (when Jim was fired in the NY production, 'new' lyrics that actually sounded suspiciously like someone turned to the original lyric sheet, crossed out the word "angel" and wrote in "vampire" were added since Jim wouldn't do the rewrite)
"There is no problem so big that it cannot be run away from."
~ Charles M. Schulz