If "..." had not won Best Musical, "..." would have

Let's remember, these are opinions, and while we can respectfully disagree with each other, it's best not to be mean to each other.

MY OPINIONS
If "Spring Awakening" had not won Best Musical, "Mary Poppins" would have
If "Jersey Boys" had not won Best Musical, "The Color Purple" would have
If "Monty Python's Spamalot" had not won Best Musical, "The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee" would have
If "Avenue Q" had not won Best Musical, "Wicked" would have
If "Hairspray" had not won Best Musical, "Movin' Out" would have
If "Thoroughly Modern Millie" had not won Best Musical, "Mamma Mia!" would have
If "The Producers" had not won Best Musical, "The Full Monty" would have
If "Contact" had not won Best Musical, "Swing!" would have
If "Fosse" had not won Best Musical, "It Ain't Nothin' But the Blues" would have
If "The Lion King" had not won Best Musical, "Ragtime" would have

Kindly go the fu*k away. See how polite I am?

---

I pretty much agree, except for a few.

If Jersey Boys had not won Best Musical, I think The Drowsy Chaperone would have.

If Thoroughly Modern Millie had not won Best Musical, I think Urinetown would have.

If Spring Awakening had not won the Tony, Grey Gardens would have. Not Mary Poppins.

Mary Poppins didn't have a chance. It should have and would have been Grey Gardens hands down.

---

If FROGS had wings they would be BUMBLEBEES.

agrees with broadwayrules

---

Totally agree about The Producers and The Full Monty. I saw them both and just hated it for The Full Monty that The Producers just about owned the Tony's that year, because I thought The Full Monty was delightful.