adam, I think you saw Frank Mastrone....not to be confused with Joe Mahowald, who was a wonderful J/H, the alternate J/H when Rob Evan took over the lead for the second time.
I called it the "Jekyll-Go-Round".... and also have my favorites and least favorites (and neither are Hasslehoff). Both Hasselhoff and Bach were both very professional to work with and geniunely nice people.
Lordy, am I actually admitting to being a "jekkie"? Well, I had many good reasons other than the show itself. J&H was the springboard for some amasingly talented, generous actors. It was some of the best times on Bd'w.
www.pbentertainmentinc.com
BWW regional writer "Philadelphia/South Jersey"