The 1991 Tony win was not unexpected. Some of the pundits (whoever they are) predicted WRF as the winner but no one thought it was the best of the 4 nominess.
MISS SAIGON came in with plenty of negative publicity (over the British cast. When Equity refused to allow them to perform, Cam Mackintosh announced he was pulling the show. Suddenly all the people who supported Equity started doing an about face and accusing the union of blocking jobs for American performers in subsequent casts, tours and even supporing roles. The union backed down but there was grumbling that the tail was wagging the dog. Well, we have heard that one before.) The reviews were mixed but favourable. Business was sensational. Tony voters however had grown weary of all the British specatcles (LES MIZ, PHNATOM and CATS) and felt that it was time to reward home grown product that seemed to need the support. One for WRF!
SECRET GARDEN opened to less than favourable reviews and after the opening the authors went to work and trimmed 20 minutes. As it stood at Tony time the show was overlong and tedious. (It never quite got over that, although the trims helped a lot.) So, it won Best Book and Daisy Egan won for best SUPPORTING actress (and her tearful speech was a highlight of the telecast) but really, she should have been up as Best Actress! Also, SECRET GARDEN is one of those shows that take a while to warm to, and it was just too new whne the awards were given out. There is a downside to opening the week before the deadline. Score Two for WRF.
ONCE ON THIS ISLAND was probably the most original of the nominees but it was considered an off-Broadway transfer and in 1991 it was not something the Tonys endorsed much. Score Three for WRF.
In the end though it was not the best musical or the best score, WRF won by default but it was a good season. All 4 shows were popular successes, 3 of the 4 made money (GARDEN did not by the time it closed but so what? It has remained popular with regionals and community groups.) And the awards seemed more evenly split up over the shows.
Cast albums are NOT "soundtracks."
Live theatre does not use a "soundtrack." If it did, it wouldn't be live theatre!
I host a weekly one-hour radio program featuring cast album selections as well as songs by cabaret, jazz and theatre artists. The program, FRONT ROW CENTRE is heard Sundays 9 to 10 am and also Saturdays from 8 to 9 am (eastern times) on www.proudfm.com