Sorry for the bump, but I just got my hands on a recording of the Coral Gables tryout (audio only, so I can't judge the full performances), and I must say I think Lee Wilkof is a much better Mushnik than the disappointing Rob Bartlett. I guess they couldn't fire Grappo without losing her husband. No one will ever top Douglas Sills as Orin (not counting Steve Martin), but Alice Ripley seems to be doing a bad Ellen Greene impression. Maybe her performance could have grown (no pun intended) if they hadn't cleaned house so unnecessarily. Billy Porter has a very different take on Audrey II, but it works, and he's very powerful vocally.
Hunter Foster was great (especially live) but I'm wondering why they kept him on and fired everyone else associated with the production (even Crystal, Chiffon and Ronette)!
Formerly SirNotAppearing - Joined 3/08