ArtMan said: "I am surprised that no one has given their review about Gardar's performance, especially after his illness. Although at my performance, Meghan was in for Christine, I did not have Murphy in as the Phantom."
I'm not at all impressed with Gardar, unfortunately. In the six performances I've seen in the past week and a half, I saw Gardar on all but two.
I much prefer Bronson in this role! While he reads as a bit young, he has excellent chemistry with both the female leads, his voice is on point, and his characterization of the phantom just reads as more genuine to me.
Whereas I find Gardar's characterization to be a bit perplexing. He doesn't seem to know what to do with his hands, and holds his arms out slightly for the bulk of the show. Think Randy from "A Christmas Story." It seems a silly thing to pick on, but it's actually really distracting! His phantom is also a bit more manic...which works in the lair scene of the original POTO show, but not as well in the context of LND. Then there's his voice... it's interesting to hear that he's recently recovered from an illness, because everything--every line, every note, seems incredibly forced. He seems to have little regard for tempo or time signature, particularly during the climax of Beneath a Moonless Sky. During one performance, I was able to look down into the orchestra pit, and at one point saw the conductor aggravatedly flipping through pages of the score trying to get back in sync with him.
Does anyone know if there's a set schedule for the covers? I know Bronson has said he's only technically scheduled on the matinees, but I'm hoping to have him for a Thursday evening performance when I have tickets!