#76
Posted: 5/29/14 at 6:08pm
But when I refer to the Medea upon which Marie Christine is based, I'm referring to the entire myth, not Euripides' work alone.
Ah...that wasn't clear. But then, it's not as if the majority of audiences are going to be that familiar with the entire myth. Even taking the entire myth in regard, LaChiusa's work is still very different.
Even My Fair Lady, adhering rather closely to Pygmalion, still has a very different feel, adapting Shaw's Anglo-Irish Socialist sensibility through an American lens.
Sounds like hair-splitting. I'm surprised you find My Fair Lady a more substantive adaptation than Hello Again, especially considering Hello Again incorporate similar changes (and more) from its original text. But if you really can't be bothered to explore it further, then I can only surmise you are simply making assumptions based on a memory of a single viewing many years ago and there may have been more to the adaptations than you care to remember. I just find it odd. As you said, you believe "substantive" is the eye of the beholder and I assume you find it more closely related to personal preference than by definition.
Ah...that wasn't clear. But then, it's not as if the majority of audiences are going to be that familiar with the entire myth. Even taking the entire myth in regard, LaChiusa's work is still very different.
Even My Fair Lady, adhering rather closely to Pygmalion, still has a very different feel, adapting Shaw's Anglo-Irish Socialist sensibility through an American lens.
Sounds like hair-splitting. I'm surprised you find My Fair Lady a more substantive adaptation than Hello Again, especially considering Hello Again incorporate similar changes (and more) from its original text. But if you really can't be bothered to explore it further, then I can only surmise you are simply making assumptions based on a memory of a single viewing many years ago and there may have been more to the adaptations than you care to remember. I just find it odd. As you said, you believe "substantive" is the eye of the beholder and I assume you find it more closely related to personal preference than by definition.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian