Ok, so it's kind of undeniable that this was a big mess, but I have to admit I liked it for some weird reason. Maybe it's the affection I have for all the "Not Since Carrie" shows out there, and this one would fit right in.
You know when you wrap your headphones around your iPod and then put it in your bag only to pull it out an hour later and find the once neatly wrapped cord in horrible knots? That's what this show is like. There might be a good show in here, but they are going to have to do A LOT of work over the preview period to straighten it out.
Raul is excellent, but then again when isn't he perfection? Unfortunately his character doesn't leave him much to work with; it's really a wonder he is able to create as many shades as he does.
Jessica Phillips has less of a role. They've made her the sheriff in this incarnation, which is a good move, but she's a little stiff and has a nice deadpan delivery, but it's hard to warm up to.
Kendra Kassebaum plays the Debra Winger role, and it's the weakest written of the three leads. She does get a nice duet with Phillips in act two, but really she should get a nice number in act one to introduce her to the audience.
The score is middle of the road. The lyrics sometimes induce a cringe (Phillips sings to Raul that even Helen Keller could see through him!). The tunes are fine though and I think on a second or third listen will really stick in my mind. Each big number is undercut by dialogue or a weak ending. Right when you're getting into it the audience is deprived of a big finish to really clap.
The book isn't embarrassing or anything, but it doesn't really tell much story in act one and is merely pedestrian in act two. As others have noted we don't care about these characters. The story is basically the same as The Music Man, with a dash of 110 in the Shade thrown in. Raul (Harold Hill) comes to town promising to change the lives of the town people. He plans on swindling them of what little money they have left. Phillips (Marion) doesn't buy it, but has fallen for him. Her son (Winthrop) is wheelchair bound and has faith Raul can make him walk again. There is also a drought and the townspeople desperately need it to rain. We all see where this is going right?
I'll absolutely be going back, and hope they untangle some of this mess, but really have to wonder what they've been doing after this had an out of town tryout and several workshops.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!