MB - right, which is why I said that there is a definite possibility that those reviewing it tonight could be completely off-base. However, I do feel that if her acting was just so completely brilliant, at least someone would have taken note and said, "Wow, maybe her voice wasn't great, but man, can she act the hell out of the song!" Again, though, I hope I've made it clear enough that I'm obviously not putting 100% faith in the few opinions that have been posted and am still looking forward to seeing the show for myself.
And yes, I think those who say her voice isn't right for the role are (in some cases, perhaps subconsciously) comparing it to others, but I think there's something to be said for what is generally considered a "traditional" musical as a whole. What seemed stranger than simply casting Daphne in the role to me was that she was cast as the only one with a truly unconventional voice. Not only does she lack a similar voice to those who have played Fantine in the past, but her voice very much defies the type of singer Les Miserables as a whole is associated with.
Additionally, I do think Daphne's voice simply sounds better when not trying to attempt slow ballads - personal opinion, but I know I'm not the only one who feels that way. Yes, Fantine led a hard life, but so did Eponine, and I wouldn't want to hear someone screech through "On My Own" just because it's true to the character. If I'm paying $100+ for a ticket, I want to hear something at least remotely pleasing to my ears (again, personal opinion).
With that, I'm off to bed. I'm looking forward to seeing what others have to say tomorrow.
Updated On: 10/25/06 at 01:09 AM
im a LES MIS virgin right now 
