I just saw the show tonight and was pleasantly surprised. Bruce Willis I think is improving a bit, because while he seemed a bit subdued at the beginning, he really seemed to come into his own throughout the rest. Laurie Metcalf is of course delivering a great performance and gives a slightly different take on the performance than Kathy Bates (she's a bit more campy and seems to know that she's a ****ing psychopath a little more than Bates' take.) It works.
The production itself was overall pleasing with a great set by David Korins. I took the $89 mid mezzanine seats (row F on the aisle) and it was a very good view. At first I thought maybe I couldn't see Metcalf too clearly but that's kinda because she looks different in this than usual (with her costume and hairstyle). Overall, it was a fun night and I'd recommend it at a mid-low price ticket.
By the way, I wasn't in the mood to stage door because I heard they were both not very nice, but I was walking around after and spotted Willis come out after about 10-15 minutes and he signed for the barricade closer to Broadway and then left. But he tipped his cap to the people on the other side and waved to the people on the other side of the street. He seemed surprisingly nice. I don't know if Laurie Metcalf came out because after Willis everyone left and they put the barricades away, but she might have come out before Willis. Just letting anyone interested know.