Now I am one of the first to get annoyed with people saying how they're excited that a show is closing, because of all the people who become unemployed, so please excuse me being a hypocrite for a moment...
Wouldn't it be funny if Young Frankenstein turned into a Pirate Queen size flop?
If Lincoln were alive today, do you think he'd be pleased with his tunnel?
"I mean, sitting side by side with another man watching Patti LuPone play Rose in GYPSY on Broadway is essentially the equivalent of having hardcore sex." -Wanna Be A Foster.
"Say 'Goody.' Say 'Bubbi.'" ... "That's it. Exactly as if it were 'Goody.' Now I know you're gonna sing 'Goody' this time, but nevertheless..."
Don't tell anyone, but yeah. From what I've gathered over the past few months Mel is an as*hole and though I wish everyone in the cast and on-stage crew continued success I hope Mel gets his just desserts. I hope the New York critics are harsh.
I'm curious: Regardless of what you think of Brooks or his work (I'm personally not a fan) WHY would you wish bad reviews on anyone?
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.
well, I hope they're honest. I'm afraid people are going to praise the show just because of Mel and the success of The Producers. If the show is not good I want them to say so.
I would want them to say so if the show is bad, but I don't know why you hope they'll be harsh. If you had seen a finished product, I would understand it, but you haven't seen it yet. It's bascially saying "You could be great!, but I hope you suck".
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.
I am a firm believer in serendipity- all the random pieces coming together in one wonderful moment, when suddenly you see what their purpose was all along.
I wont lie, my heart isn't into supporting this show at the moment. But that doesn't mean I wish for it to fail.
For Megan Mullally's sake in particular I actually wish it all the best. I love her and I hope this gives her a chance to shine more than her talk show allowed her to.
As for Brooks, IF his reputation for being egotistical is true, and IF he actually IS as arrogant as he has come across, then I think he deserves to get fed a plate of humble pie. Not necessarily with this show. Perhaps in another area of his life where other innocent people wont be forced to take a taste. Just him alone, with a big fat fork of it.
Yeah, I know how people can get on this site, but come on! People are actually putting down Mel Brooks for the sake of The Pirate Queen? That makes no sense!!!
Not necessarily for Queen though, I don't really like PQ or Mel and yet it seems that Brooks is able to make people dislike him enough on his own merits. If anything, people are disliking Frankenstein for the sake that Mel Brooks is behind it, but I don't really see the criticism coming at him because of the Pirate Queen's sake as much.
OK, then why all this sudden hatred of Mel Brooks? I thought it all started when he announced YF was taking the Hilton. I also thought he was very well respected, at least in Hollywood, and he is a comic genious.
I'm not being cruel and I'm not putting him or his show down for the sake of The Pirate Queen.
I believe in karma and in people in general getting back what they put out. And I purposefully capitalized "IF" to be fair to him. For all I know the press may have spun his quotes giving him a bad wrap.
Some people don't think he's said anything inappropriate at all so I guess it depends on how you see it.
"For all I know the press may have spun his quotes giving him a bad wrap."
First of all, Popular I wasn't really addressing you becuase you added the ifs in, I want to know what press gave Brooks a bad name. If you guys are talking about the article where he announced the theater that YF was going to play at, there was nothing egotistical about that.
I also don't think it is fair in general to ridicule people who have done so much for a certain art form.
For me it's not necessarily WHAT, but rather HOW and WHEN he said what he did.
He ran his mouth a little too much and too soon for my taste. I should also say that I can think poorly of how he handled this particular situation and still respect his past contibutions. Some of the brightest, most talented people are creeps so I don't see how one thing has to do with the other.
It could just be how he interviewed at the time. Unfortunately, the Pirate Queen only drew in average reviews. Not every show does well. I hope though that some of it's performers find work with Mel's new musical. I think I will like YF more than The Producers, yet it wasn't a bad show either.
I thought Mel had a couple of options as to where to put his revival down in. It was up to the Hilton, so they must have been ready to try something new.
Unfortunately, Mel is getting old, his great Wife is gone, it may have soured him some. If he is harsh, I hope whoever got the shaft from him, tells him so and hopefully, he will straighten out some. I think it is easy to forget that the Actors auditioning are people not commodities. Though meeting deadlines puts a lot of pressure on everyone.
I think Sutton Foster will do a great job in YF, so I hope it does well. It has some really good, funny parts, so I hope the cast is able to have some fun with the show.