OK, this could take a while ... I've been seeing shows since I was 6 years old. So bear with me for the next 25 years ...
Annie (Forrest Theatre, Philly, 1980)
They're Playing Our Song (Forrest Theatre, Philly, 1981)
Evita (Forrest Theatre, Philly, 1982)
Peter Pan (Academy of Music, Philly, 1982, 2005)
42nd Street (My first Broadway show, Majestic Theatre, 1987)
The Phantom of the Opera (Majestic Theatre, 1989)
Aspects of Love (Broadhurst Theatre, 1990)
Miss Saigon (Broadway Theatre, 1991)
Gypsy (Marquis Theatre, 1991, Shubert Theatre, 2003)
Man of La Mancha (Marquis Theatre, 1992, Martin Beck 2004)
Blood Brothers (Music Box Theatre, 1993)
Joseph (Minskoff Theatre, 1993)
Carousel (LCT, 1994)
Sunset Blvd. (Minskoff Theatre, 1994 - I saw it 7 times)
Titanic (Lunt-Fontanne, 1997)
The Life (Barrymore Theatre, 1997)
Side Show (Richard Rodgers Theatre, 1997)
Ragtime (Ford Center, 199
Cabaret (Henry Miller Theatre, 199
The Dead (Playwright's Horizon, 1999)
Parade (LCT, 1999 - I saw the last day)
The Rocky Horror Show (Circle in the Square, 2000)
The Spitfire Grill (The Duke Theatre, 2001)
Mamma Mia (Winter Garden, 2001)
By Jeeves (Helen Hayes Theatre, 2001)
Thoroughly Modern Millie (Marquis Theatre, 2002)
Hairspray (Neil Simon Theatre, 2003)
The Great American Trailer Park Musical (Dodger Stages, 2005)
The Woman in White (Marquis Theatre, 2005)
Sweeney Todd (Eugene O'Neill Theatre, 2005)
I'm sure I'm missing some. I can't think straight. The list of shows I flippin' hated is a whole other issue! Where to begin?!? Not to mention all the wonderful regional productions and even some wonderful community theatre productions. There's just no way to stop the madness!

And I'd have it no other way.