I think Brooklyn will hold it's own. There are some better songs in the show than the ones available on the website. It scares me that Eden Espinoza is already getting so much attention already. (Although, I am sure they are pushing her to the forefront) But trust me, the 2 other ladies in this show can pretty much go toe to toe with her in the singing department. It is a pretty light show and the story is not really complicated at all. I think that critics may not be happy with some of the staging. (You do have to use your imagination. That doesn't always go over well!!) Having seen it a few times, I couldn't help but think of RENT. The set just has that feel to it. (And based on the sketches, they have not changed it much, it at all from the Denver run) The music is not as rock oriented as RENT. The cast plays street people. The whole show is a "street performance". I can't see critics ripping it to shreds, but I can see them calling it a light, fun evening at the theatre. It will be interesting to see what they have done with the book. It could use some tightening up a bit. And the "sing off" scene in the second act should be tightened up a bit also. (In my opinion) As I said in another thread, I think it will appeal to a wide audience. and, as stated before, I was very impressed by the sound design. Cool city sound effects swirled around the theatre in Denver. A friend associated with the show has also told me that the audience participation has been removed from the second act. That could change however. (I hope not. It didn't go over well with myself and a lot of people I know who saw it) In my opinion, If you liked Wicked or RENT, (Just using those shows as there have been comparisons)this show should be right up your alley.
Just give the world Love. - S. Wonder